尊敬的 微信汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046239 元 支付宝汇率:1円 ≈ 0.04633元 [退出登录]
SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Structural Engineering
Civil Engineering Department
MNNIT ALLAHABAD
Supervisor(s) –
Dr. L.K. MISHRA
Dr. GOUTAM GHOSH
Presented By-
Lovneesh Modi
2016ST02
A SUMMER PROJECT PRESENTATION
On
Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building
Under Static And Dynamic Loads
List of Contents
1.Introduction
2.Objectives
3.Methodology
4.Problem Definition
5.Results
6.Conclusion
7.Reference
Introduction
Foundation is the structure element that transfers the load from column or load
bearing wall to ground.
It can be classified as :-
1. Shallow :-Depth upto 2 m
2. Deep :- Depth more than 2m
We are focusing on the each of the two types of shallow foundation:-
1. Isolated column footing
2. Mat/Raft foundation
Image source:- strucalc.com
Objectives
• To evaluate the Soil Bearing capacity according to IS 6403-1987 and
Settlement from the available Bore log data
• To identify the suitable type of foundation for given condition
• To design the foundations using Staad Foundation advanced
Methodology
• Application of problem formulated by analyzing it in Staad-Pro
• Export the reactions from Staad Pro to the Staad foundation
Advanced for modeling, analysis and design of the foundations
• Comparison of the Results in terms of SBC, Settlement and Quantity
of materials
Problem Definition
The dimensions taken are as follows:-
• Beams 300x450mm2 and Column 500x500mm2
• Dead load 3.75kN/m2 (assume 150mm slab)
• Floor to floor height is 3m and column to column distance is 10m
• Live load 2 kN/m2 (according to IS 875 Part2-1987)
• Wind load taken according to IS 875 Part3-2015
• Seismic Loads are taken according to IS 1893 Part1-1993
FOUNDATION DESIGN
DEFINE
ASSUMPTIONS
DESIGN CHECK AND
REINFORCEMENT
DESIGN
STRUCTURAL
ANALYSIS
PRELIMINARY
DESIGN BASED ON
SERVICE LOAD
Soil Bearing
Capacity
Depth of footing
Water Table
Concrete and
soil Unit Weight
Calculate required
foundation
dimension based
on required area
Required
foundation area
Calculate
factored footing
pressure
Calculate
maximum shear
Calculate
maximum
moment
Overturning
Sliding
One way shear
Punching shear
Choose governing area
of steel and determine
spacing required
CHECK
Calculate
maximum
moment
Advantages/Disadvantages
of the Staad Foundation
Advantages Disadvantages
Quick and easy assessment of stresses Settlement calculation is not possible
Effortless design of footing according to IS 456-2000 Calculation of SBC for isolated column footing is to be
manually provided
Quick extraction of detail drawing of the structural
component(only for isolated and combined footing)
Collaboration of model with BIM workflow is yet not
possible
Results
Isolated(square) Raft
Safe bearing capacity 235 kN/m2 least calculated 476 kN/m2
Settlement 144 mm(allowable 60 mm) 65mm(allowable 75 mm)
Maximum dimension 3.85x3.85 - 6.3x6.3 m2 35 x 45 m2
Thickness of footing 450 - 670 mm 600mm
Concrete 432m3 945 m3
Steel 33.868x 103 Tonnes 2.921x 103 Tonnes
Cost of concrete excluding
centering and shuttering(in Rs)
33,64,848(@7789 per m3) 73,60,605(@7789 per m3)
Cost of steel (in Rs) 2,16,75,52,000(@ 64 per kg) 18,69,44,000(@64 per kg)
Total Cost(in Rs) 2,17,09,16,848 19,43,04,605
Footing
Name
Settlement
(mm)
Square Size(m) X
(m)
Z
(m)
SBC(kN/m2) Base Pressure
(kN/m2)
footing 1 61 5.15 0 0 244 55
footing 2 78 6.15 10 0 252 78
footing 3 78 6.15 20 0 252 70
footing 4 61 5.15 30 0 244 55
footing 25 79 6.1 0 10 251 70
footing26 144 5.75 10 10 248 130
footing 27 144 5.75 20 10 248 131
footing 28 114 4.8 30 10 241 105
footing 49 75 6.3 0 20 253 66
footing 50 139 5.85 10 20 249 126
footing 51 137 5.95 20 20 250 123
footing 52 114 4.8 30 20 241 104
footing 73 79 6.1 0 30 251 70
footing 74 141 5.8 10 30 249 129
footing 75 142 5.8 20 30 249 129
footing 76 112 4.85 30 30 241 103
footing 97 62 5.1 0 40 243 55
footing 98 118 4.7 10 40 240 110
footing 99 116 4.75 20 40 240 108
footing 10097 3.85 30 40 235
94
The maximum Base pressures or reaction of the mat comes out to be 79 kN/m2and average reaction is 10 kN/m2.
The maximum bearing Stresses in mat is 29.5 N/mm2 and average is 3.76 N/mm2
Conclusion
• For the frame structure and given soil type Raft foundation comes out
to be most efficient in terms of settlement , strength and economy
• Design of bearing stresses being important in Raft for which
additional reinforcement in the form of dowel bars should be
provided.
References
1. IS 1893 – 1993Part 1 “Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structure”
2. IS 1904 – 1986 ”Design and Construction of Foundation in Soils”
3. IS 6403 – 1981 ”Determination of Breaking Capacity of Shallow Foundation”
4. IS 456 -2000 ”Plain and Reinforced Concrete”
5. CPWD Detail Schedule of Rates (2014)
Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building Under Static And Dynamic Loads

More Related Content

What's hot

Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to SupportsShear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
Eva Lantsoght
 
Pile cap design structural guide
Pile cap design   structural guidePile cap design   structural guide
Pile cap design structural guide
Alberto Rosado
 
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importanceLecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
Dr. H.M.A. Mahzuz
 
Bridge construction-railway
Bridge construction-railwayBridge construction-railway
Bridge construction-railway
pritam choudhary
 
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKINGMULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
Manoj Navneeth
 
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
CADmantra Technologies
 
Stepped footing
Stepped footingStepped footing
Stepped footing
Pritesh Parmar
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
Ali Abuzant
 
IRJET- Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
IRJET-  	  Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension SlabIRJET-  	  Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
IRJET- Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
IRJET Journal
 
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
Kumar Aman
 
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVERDESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
ManiKandan1175
 
Pt slab design philosophy with slides and pictures showing benefit
Pt slab design philosophy  with slides and pictures showing benefitPt slab design philosophy  with slides and pictures showing benefit
Pt slab design philosophy with slides and pictures showing benefit
Perwez Ahmad
 
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERSANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
IAEME Publication
 
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETESTUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
Shoaib Wani
 
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
Shoaib Wani
 
post tensioning slabs
post tensioning slabspost tensioning slabs
post tensioning slabs
gopichand's
 
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
IJERA Editor
 
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road ProjectChittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
Rakibul Haque
 
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
guestac67362
 
Ppt rcc road design
Ppt rcc road designPpt rcc road design
Ppt rcc road design
Anjani Shukla
 

What's hot (20)

Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to SupportsShear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
Shear in Reinforced Concrete Slabs under Concentrated Loads close to Supports
 
Pile cap design structural guide
Pile cap design   structural guidePile cap design   structural guide
Pile cap design structural guide
 
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importanceLecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
Lecture 1 what is rcc column and its importance
 
Bridge construction-railway
Bridge construction-railwayBridge construction-railway
Bridge construction-railway
 
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKINGMULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
MULTI-STOREY CAR PARKING
 
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
Analysisanddesignofamulti storey staad pro.
 
Stepped footing
Stepped footingStepped footing
Stepped footing
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
IRJET- Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
IRJET-  	  Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension SlabIRJET-  	  Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
IRJET- Cost Analysis of Two-Way Slab and Post Tension Slab
 
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
A Comperative study of Analysis of a G+3 Residential Building by the Equivale...
 
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVERDESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
DESIGN OF POST TENSIONED DECK SLAB FOR FLYOVER
 
Pt slab design philosophy with slides and pictures showing benefit
Pt slab design philosophy  with slides and pictures showing benefitPt slab design philosophy  with slides and pictures showing benefit
Pt slab design philosophy with slides and pictures showing benefit
 
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERSANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARATIVE STUDY OF COMPOSITE BRIDGE GIRDERS
 
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETESTUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
STUDY ON BOND MECHANISM OF PSWC BARS WITH CONCRETE
 
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
STUDY ON INFLUENCE OF RIB CONFIGURATION ON BOND STRENGTH DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN ...
 
post tensioning slabs
post tensioning slabspost tensioning slabs
post tensioning slabs
 
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
The hanging basket stress calculation and stability analysis during cantileve...
 
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road ProjectChittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
Chittagong City Outer Ring Road Project
 
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
320103 Basic Structural Steel Design And Drawing
 
Ppt rcc road design
Ppt rcc road designPpt rcc road design
Ppt rcc road design
 

Similar to Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building Under Static And Dynamic Loads

Hospital building project
Hospital building projectHospital building project
Hospital building project
sasi vijayalakshmi
 
ppt mini project 7.pptx
ppt mini project 7.pptxppt mini project 7.pptx
ppt mini project 7.pptx
SRUTHIRAJ18
 
Lecture22.pdf
Lecture22.pdfLecture22.pdf
Lecture22.pdf
Prantik Adhar Samanta
 
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
IRJET Journal
 
Flat_slab.pptx
Flat_slab.pptxFlat_slab.pptx
Flat_slab.pptx
ssuserdd13b81
 
sruthi ppt.pptx
sruthi ppt.pptxsruthi ppt.pptx
sruthi ppt.pptx
SRUTHIRAJ18
 
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridge
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridgeAnalysis & design of T-Beam bridge
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridge
Elamathy Murugan
 
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete StructureStructural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
IJERA Editor
 
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
IRJET Journal
 
Segmental Lining Design Presentation
Segmental Lining Design PresentationSegmental Lining Design Presentation
Segmental Lining Design Presentation
Keith Kong
 
addition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pileaddition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pile
TharachJanesupasaere
 
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdfPile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
MehdiEbadi10
 
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING PROJECT REPORT
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING  PROJECT  REPORTG+3 APARTMENT BUILDING  PROJECT  REPORT
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING PROJECT REPORT
Fresher Thinking
 
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAMF.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
IRJET Journal
 
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasancivil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
Engr Mirza S Hasan
 
Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
 Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table. Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
onkar solshe
 
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & ApplicationsCulvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
Path Marketing Inc.
 
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation ProjectsEssential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
Erbil Polytechnic University
 
swati structure.ipt
swati structure.iptswati structure.ipt
swati structure.ipt
Abhishek Prasad
 
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
IrshadKhan97473
 

Similar to Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building Under Static And Dynamic Loads (20)

Hospital building project
Hospital building projectHospital building project
Hospital building project
 
ppt mini project 7.pptx
ppt mini project 7.pptxppt mini project 7.pptx
ppt mini project 7.pptx
 
Lecture22.pdf
Lecture22.pdfLecture22.pdf
Lecture22.pdf
 
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
IRJET- Study & Improvement of Design and Construction Methodology of Precast ...
 
Flat_slab.pptx
Flat_slab.pptxFlat_slab.pptx
Flat_slab.pptx
 
sruthi ppt.pptx
sruthi ppt.pptxsruthi ppt.pptx
sruthi ppt.pptx
 
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridge
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridgeAnalysis & design of T-Beam bridge
Analysis & design of T-Beam bridge
 
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete StructureStructural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
Structural Design and Rehabilitation of Reinforced Concrete Structure
 
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
IRJET- A Technical Approach to Flat Slab Multistorey Building under Wind Spee...
 
Segmental Lining Design Presentation
Segmental Lining Design PresentationSegmental Lining Design Presentation
Segmental Lining Design Presentation
 
addition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pileaddition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pile
 
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdfPile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
Pile Foundations v1.00 Oct2010.pdf
 
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING PROJECT REPORT
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING  PROJECT  REPORTG+3 APARTMENT BUILDING  PROJECT  REPORT
G+3 APARTMENT BUILDING PROJECT REPORT
 
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAMF.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
F.E.M ANALYSIS OF ANNULAR MAT FOUNDATION WITH & WITHOUT ANNULAR BEAM
 
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasancivil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
civil_engg_thesis_F inal presentation_mirzaShasan
 
Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
 Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table. Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
Base Isolation of Building Frames- Experimental Study Using Shake Table.
 
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & ApplicationsCulvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
Culvert Design 201 Structural Design, Durability & Applications
 
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation ProjectsEssential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
Essential Design Criteria for Safe Braced Cuts in Excavation Projects
 
swati structure.ipt
swati structure.iptswati structure.ipt
swati structure.ipt
 
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
36405231_seismic_design_steps_153.ppt
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call GirlCall Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
sapna sharmap11
 
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
simrangupta87541
 
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptxLiterature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
LokerXu2
 
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Banerescorts
 
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdfFUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
EMERSON EDUARDO RODRIGUES
 
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
DharmaBanothu
 
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
nonods
 
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdfSELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
Pallavi Sharma
 
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdfSri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Balvir Singh
 
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
adhaniomprakash
 
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptxMODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
NaveenNaveen726446
 
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineeringTENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
SnehalChavan75
 
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
AK47
 
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdfCovid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
DharmaBanothu
 
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
sonamrawat5631
 
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptxLateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
DebendraDevKhanal1
 
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort ServiceCuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
yakranividhrini
 
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdfMy Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
Geoffrey Wardle. MSc. MSc. Snr.MAIAA
 
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
supriyaDicholkar1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call GirlCall Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
 
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
Mahipalpur Call Girls Delhi 🔥 9711199012 ❄- Pick Your Dream Call Girls with 1...
 
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptxLiterature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
Literature review for prompt engineering of ChatGPT.pptx
 
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
 
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdfFUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
FUNDAMENTALS OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING.pdf
 
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
This study Examines the Effectiveness of Talent Procurement through the Imple...
 
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
 
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdfSELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
SELENIUM CONF -PALLAVI SHARMA - 2024.pdf
 
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdfSri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
 
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
🔥LiploCk Call Girls Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Escorts Ser...
 
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptxMODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
MODULE 5 BIOLOGY FOR ENGINEERS TRENDS IN BIO ENGINEERING.pptx
 
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineeringTENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
 
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
🔥Independent Call Girls In Pune 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Pune Esco...
 
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdfCovid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
 
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
 
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
🔥Young College Call Girls Chandigarh 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent Chan...
 
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptxLateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
 
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort ServiceCuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
Cuttack Call Girls 💯Call Us 🔝 7374876321 🔝 💃 Independent Female Escort Service
 
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdfMy Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
 
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
Introduction to Artificial Intelligence.
 

Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building Under Static And Dynamic Loads

  • 1. Structural Engineering Civil Engineering Department MNNIT ALLAHABAD Supervisor(s) – Dr. L.K. MISHRA Dr. GOUTAM GHOSH Presented By- Lovneesh Modi 2016ST02 A SUMMER PROJECT PRESENTATION On Comparison Of Square And Raft Footing For A Multistory Building Under Static And Dynamic Loads
  • 2. List of Contents 1.Introduction 2.Objectives 3.Methodology 4.Problem Definition 5.Results 6.Conclusion 7.Reference
  • 3. Introduction Foundation is the structure element that transfers the load from column or load bearing wall to ground. It can be classified as :- 1. Shallow :-Depth upto 2 m 2. Deep :- Depth more than 2m We are focusing on the each of the two types of shallow foundation:- 1. Isolated column footing 2. Mat/Raft foundation Image source:- strucalc.com
  • 4. Objectives • To evaluate the Soil Bearing capacity according to IS 6403-1987 and Settlement from the available Bore log data • To identify the suitable type of foundation for given condition • To design the foundations using Staad Foundation advanced
  • 5. Methodology • Application of problem formulated by analyzing it in Staad-Pro • Export the reactions from Staad Pro to the Staad foundation Advanced for modeling, analysis and design of the foundations • Comparison of the Results in terms of SBC, Settlement and Quantity of materials
  • 6. Problem Definition The dimensions taken are as follows:- • Beams 300x450mm2 and Column 500x500mm2 • Dead load 3.75kN/m2 (assume 150mm slab) • Floor to floor height is 3m and column to column distance is 10m • Live load 2 kN/m2 (according to IS 875 Part2-1987) • Wind load taken according to IS 875 Part3-2015 • Seismic Loads are taken according to IS 1893 Part1-1993
  • 7. FOUNDATION DESIGN DEFINE ASSUMPTIONS DESIGN CHECK AND REINFORCEMENT DESIGN STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS PRELIMINARY DESIGN BASED ON SERVICE LOAD Soil Bearing Capacity Depth of footing Water Table Concrete and soil Unit Weight Calculate required foundation dimension based on required area Required foundation area Calculate factored footing pressure Calculate maximum shear Calculate maximum moment Overturning Sliding One way shear Punching shear Choose governing area of steel and determine spacing required CHECK Calculate maximum moment
  • 8. Advantages/Disadvantages of the Staad Foundation Advantages Disadvantages Quick and easy assessment of stresses Settlement calculation is not possible Effortless design of footing according to IS 456-2000 Calculation of SBC for isolated column footing is to be manually provided Quick extraction of detail drawing of the structural component(only for isolated and combined footing) Collaboration of model with BIM workflow is yet not possible
  • 9. Results Isolated(square) Raft Safe bearing capacity 235 kN/m2 least calculated 476 kN/m2 Settlement 144 mm(allowable 60 mm) 65mm(allowable 75 mm) Maximum dimension 3.85x3.85 - 6.3x6.3 m2 35 x 45 m2 Thickness of footing 450 - 670 mm 600mm Concrete 432m3 945 m3 Steel 33.868x 103 Tonnes 2.921x 103 Tonnes Cost of concrete excluding centering and shuttering(in Rs) 33,64,848(@7789 per m3) 73,60,605(@7789 per m3) Cost of steel (in Rs) 2,16,75,52,000(@ 64 per kg) 18,69,44,000(@64 per kg) Total Cost(in Rs) 2,17,09,16,848 19,43,04,605
  • 10. Footing Name Settlement (mm) Square Size(m) X (m) Z (m) SBC(kN/m2) Base Pressure (kN/m2) footing 1 61 5.15 0 0 244 55 footing 2 78 6.15 10 0 252 78 footing 3 78 6.15 20 0 252 70 footing 4 61 5.15 30 0 244 55 footing 25 79 6.1 0 10 251 70 footing26 144 5.75 10 10 248 130 footing 27 144 5.75 20 10 248 131 footing 28 114 4.8 30 10 241 105 footing 49 75 6.3 0 20 253 66 footing 50 139 5.85 10 20 249 126 footing 51 137 5.95 20 20 250 123 footing 52 114 4.8 30 20 241 104 footing 73 79 6.1 0 30 251 70 footing 74 141 5.8 10 30 249 129 footing 75 142 5.8 20 30 249 129 footing 76 112 4.85 30 30 241 103 footing 97 62 5.1 0 40 243 55 footing 98 118 4.7 10 40 240 110 footing 99 116 4.75 20 40 240 108 footing 10097 3.85 30 40 235 94
  • 11. The maximum Base pressures or reaction of the mat comes out to be 79 kN/m2and average reaction is 10 kN/m2. The maximum bearing Stresses in mat is 29.5 N/mm2 and average is 3.76 N/mm2
  • 12. Conclusion • For the frame structure and given soil type Raft foundation comes out to be most efficient in terms of settlement , strength and economy • Design of bearing stresses being important in Raft for which additional reinforcement in the form of dowel bars should be provided.
  • 13. References 1. IS 1893 – 1993Part 1 “Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structure” 2. IS 1904 – 1986 ”Design and Construction of Foundation in Soils” 3. IS 6403 – 1981 ”Determination of Breaking Capacity of Shallow Foundation” 4. IS 456 -2000 ”Plain and Reinforced Concrete” 5. CPWD Detail Schedule of Rates (2014)
  翻译: