Duo-YM&AF-Architecture Education vs Practice Debate-29Sep.pdf

•

0 likes•6 views

Education and Practice are two crucial aspects of any profession. They complement each other and play distinct roles in an architect's career development.

Architecture: Education vs Practice
Education and Practice are two crucial
aspects of any profession. They
complement each other and play distinct
roles in an architect's career development.
Profession
Education Practice

Architecture:
Education Vs Practice
Educator
Practitioner

Rules
• The debates will follow the “Karl Popper
Debate” format that focuses on relevant
and often deeply divisive propositions,
emphasizing critical thinking, and
tolerance for differing viewpoints.
• Debates will be judged by the audience.

Guidelines
• The debate should:
– Focus on the core elements of controversial
issues.
– Emphasize tolerance for multiple points of
view.
– Stress analytical thinking.
– Appreciate different view points.
– Provide opportunity to debate and reach
resolutions.

Debate Format
• Two teams.
• Topic.
• One team PRO and one
team AGAINST.
• 3 Minutes for PRO team.
• 3 Minutes for AGAINST
team.
• Audience judgment by
clapping.
PRO AGAINST

Format
7 Minutes Debate
Order Time
Affirmative Construct 3 Minutes
Negative Construct 3 Minutes
Audience Voting 0.5 Minute
Result 0.5 Minute

Formal Training
Education should
provide the
foundational
knowledge and skills
required to become an
architect.
Education Does Not Teach!

Theoretical Knowledge
Practice Does Not Use!
Education teaches
theoretical knowledge
about architecture,
including design
concepts, historical
context, and
contemporary trends.

Client Interaction
Education Does Not Teach!
Architects in practice
collaborate with
clients, contractors,
engineers, and other
professionals to bring
architectural designs to
life.

Research and Innovation
Architectural education
encourages research and
innovation, enabling
students to explore new
materials, technologies,
and sustainable design
practices.
Practice Does Not Use!

Regulatory Knowledge
Education Does Not Teach!
Architects learn
about building
codes, regulations,
and ethics, which are
essential for
designing safe and
compliant structures.

Balancing
Education and Practice
Balancing education and practice is
essential for architects to excel in
their careers.

Balancing
Education and Practice
1. Strong Foundation: Knowledge and skills that
architects can draw upon throughout their
careers.
2. Applied Learning: Apply education in real-world
scenarios, gaining practical experience and
refining their abilities.
3. Adaptability: Updated with the latest trends
and technologies, and adapt to changing
circumstances.
4. Career Advancement: Better positioned for
career advancement and specialization.
5. Innovation: fosters innovation in architecture,
leading to sustainable and creative solutions.

Balancing
Education and Practice
Education and Practice are Intertwined.
Education provides the knowledge and theory,
while
Practice offers the opportunity to apply that
knowledge in real projects.

Balancing
Education and Practice
Successful architects maintain a balance
between these two aspects, as it
enables them to develop into skilled
professionals capable of creating
innovative and impactful designs.

PHL/320 Critical Thinking and Decision Making in Business Copyright ©2014 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. SYLLABUS Course Description This course explores the critical thinking techniques necessary to be an effective manager within an organizational setting. Students will focus on critical-thinking and reasoning methods as they apply to management concepts within a work environment. Other topics include the use of critical thinking skills in the decision-making process as it applies to expectations for successful performance of employees and organizations and achieving desired business goals. Course Dates Sep 30, 2014 - Nov 03, 2014 Faculty Information • Academic Policies University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly different depending on the modality in which you attend class. If you have recently changed modalities, read the policies governing your current class modality. Get Ready for Class • Familiarize yourself with the textbooks used in this course. Course Materials All electronic materials are available on your student website. Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents (both located on your student website): Policies JENNIFER STEPHENS (PRIMARY)Name : Email Address : [email protected] Alternate Email Address Phone Number : Not Available Week1 Sep, 30 - Oct, 06 Basics of Critical Thinking Tasks 1.1 Describe the importance of critical thinking to the decision-making process. 1.2 Differentiate among types of reasoning and critical thinking. 1.3 Explain common cognitive biases. Objectives/Competencies Required Learning Activities • Critical Thinking, Ch. 1 • Critical Thinking, Ch. 2 • Critical Thinking, Ch. 3 • Week One Electronic Reserve Readings • Knowledge Check Personalized Study Guide • Critical Thinking Ch. 1, 2, & 3 Microsoft® PowerPoint® Presentations • Critical Thinking Ch. 1 Multiple Choice Quiz • Critical Thinking Ch. 2 Multiple Choice Quiz • Critical Thinking Ch. 3 Multiple Choice Quiz • Gates Go Back to School Video • Introduction • Learning Team Assignments See the student website for additional recommended learning activities that may help you learn this week's concepts. Title Type Due Points Week 1 Participation Participate in class discussion. Individual Oct 06, 2014 11:59 PM 2 Critical Analysis Worksheet Read "Common Core" and "The Battle Against Common Core Standards." Complete the University of Phoenix Material: Critical Analysis Worksheet. Individual Oct 06, 2014 11:59 PM 2 Critical Thinking Discussion and Summary Participate in a class discussion by responding to the following questions: • How would you define critical thinking? What makes a person a critical thinker? • Why is critical thinking important? Provide an example of how critical thinking has helped you.

Writing Conference Proposals

Aiden Yeh

This document provides guidance on writing and submitting effective conference proposals. It discusses the proposal submission process, important components like the abstract and summary, and tips for a successful proposal. Key points covered include following submission guidelines, clearly relating the topic to the field, describing what will be done and how attendees will benefit, and keeping the abstract under 300 words. Effective titles, length, structure and language are also addressed.

Team Building Workshop

Sabry66

This document outlines a team building workshop for first-year engineering students. It discusses the importance of teamwork skills for career success. Students will complete exercises to practice teamwork, including designing the longest spanning beam. They will also discuss forming team agreements and roles to enhance performance. The workshop aims to provide an overview of team organization and skills like communication, conflict resolution, and accountability.

DESIGN AND ENGINEERING.pptx

shyamraj1981

The document provides information about a course on design and engineering. It outlines the course objectives, which are to introduce students to fundamental design principles, the design process, and basic design tools. The course outcomes are for students to be able to explain design concepts and principles, apply design thinking, and develop innovative and sustainable designs. It then discusses various aspects of design such as what design is, engineering design principles, the differences between engineering design and other types of design. It also outlines the steps in the engineering design process.

Multimedia learning: 2002-18: A case study across a century of digital learning

York University - Osgoode Hall Law School

This document summarizes the development of multimedia learning resources from 2002 to 2018 at the Glasgow Graduate School of Law. It describes the contexts and educational theories that informed the resources, the development process across 3 phases, feedback from students, and costs and savings. The resources were developed to support the Foundation Course and modeled legal skills for students through interactive videos and text.

Design requirements for supporting young designers with conflicts at work

Lenny van Onselen

If we want future designers to act responsibly, they have to be aware of values. Young designers are hired for fresh ideas. Nonetheless, they frequently experience value differences with clients, co-workers and other stakeholders when they bring these ideas to the table. Support might be improved for junior design professionals to better cope with value-based conflicts. They can act with purpose and come to grips with value-based conflicts, solving value differences in a more integrative and constructive way. In this presentation, I present the first steps of an action research. Based on the insights from the study, we have formulated requirements to educate and to facilitate junior design professionals to improve reflection on critical situations at work based on value differences.

21idt.pdf

Ekta Jolly

This document provides information on a course titled "Innovation and Design Thinking". It includes details such as the course code, credits, teaching hours, assessment details, modules, and learning outcomes. The course aims to explain concepts of design thinking, innovation, and implementing design in real world problems. It covers topics like the design process, tools for collaboration, applying design thinking to business and IT, and strategic innovations. Assessment includes continuous internal evaluations like tests and assignments, and a semester end examination. The course intends to help students appreciate design processes, generate design ideas, and identify the role of reverse engineering in products.

Best Interior Design Colleges in Mumbai

seemagup9

The Interior Design Professional Program aims to provide knowledge on designing interior spaces. It consists of 6 courses over 270 hours that cover topics like human factors, design principles, styles, materials, presentation techniques, and a final design project. The program teaches conceptual design, analysis, theme development, and functional space planning. Students learn presentation skills, material selection, and how to effectively communicate design proposals. The goal is to prepare participants to successfully design interior spaces and integrate human, aesthetic, and functional requirements.

Lezing Cohousing Architect Laura Fitch (USA) - efficiënte ontwerpsessies

Sofie Deberdt

Lecture 1.pdfgjgfddfbnnngdsdvnncxzxcbnssdfh

TemesgenErena

This document provides an overview and outline for a Mechanical Engineering Design Project course (MECH 390). It discusses expectations for the course which include completing a design project in a team, taking a midterm exam, tutorials, and quizzes. Students are expected to apply engineering skills to open-ended problems through concepts, solutions, planning, decision making, modeling, prototyping, and communication. Success requires attention in lectures, studying documentation, and attendance to learn skills needed for engineering design in their career.

Protocols for Professional Conversations

Cameron Paterson

This document provides an overview of protocols for guiding professional conversations. It discusses what protocols are, how they can help deepen understanding of teaching and learning, and how they are used. Protocols provide structures for conversations and ensure clarity of purpose, safety, equity and opportunities for reflection. Examples of specific protocols are provided, such as the microlab protocol and collaborative assessment conference protocol. Guidelines are offered for using protocols effectively and challenges are acknowledged, such as taking time to learn them and resisting the urge to problem-solve prematurely.

unit 2 ppt of engineering design and modeling

ISHANAMRITSRIVASTAVA

Fue theory 4 lecture 6 - methods of evaluation and design development

Galala University

This document discusses methods of evaluating architectural design quality and building performance. It outlines four main areas of design quality: impact, build quality, functionality, and value. Design evaluation and post-occupancy evaluation are two types of evaluation discussed. Post-occupancy evaluation involves assessing a building's performance after it is occupied and can provide benefits like improving future building designs and measuring if a building meets its intended functions. The document presents models for conducting post-occupancy evaluations and examples of how evaluations have been applied.

Project management.docx communiction

berhanu taye

The document discusses project management and the roles and responsibilities of a project leader. It provides details on the various tasks involved in planning, managing, and delivering documentation projects, including administrative tasks, writing tasks, client relations tasks, and common problems and solutions. It emphasizes the importance of communication, establishing expectations, identifying information sources, and facilitating effective draft reviews. The overall aim is to educate readers on best practices for leading documentation projects successfully.

Speed design studio version4.6

Jabe Bloom

Speed Design Studio is a variant of Will Evan’s Design Studio Process and was designed collaboratively by Jabe Bloom and Will Evan’s at TLCLabs Speed Design Studio was modified from the original based on insights from Cognitive Edge methods and is focused on extremely rapid iterations in an attempt to emerge team level understandings of design problems and solution language. Due to efforts applied to tighten cycle times, Speed Design Studio can be taught in a 1-2 hr workshop.

Answering question 1 a

Andy Wallis

The document provides advice for answering exam questions about developing skills and creative practice in media production. It outlines five key areas that may be covered: digital technology, research and planning, conventions of real media, post-production, and creativity. Students are advised to prepare examples from their work to demonstrate how their skills developed over multiple projects. Questions may require discussing two combined areas, so students need to consider various pairings.

Ready, Set, Critique!

Adam Connor

Critique is a type of structured feedback that examines what works and doesn't work in a design from the perspective of the audience and goals. It should provide specific, actionable feedback. Incorporating critique into the design process provides benefits like new ideas, improved communication skills, and collaboration. Critiques can be done internally at different stages of a project or with clients. They work best with 3-6 diverse participants and last 30-60 minutes. Ground rules and clear goals help critiques run effectively. With practice, critique is a skill that can improve design work.

The importance of co creation in learning space design - presentation

Greg Bold

The document discusses engaging students and staff in the design of learning spaces on campus. It provides examples of projects where students and staff were involved in the design, testing, and evaluation of new classrooms and library spaces. Student and staff feedback was gathered, and in some cases led to redesigns that simplified the spaces. Principles for engagement were developed that emphasized ease of access, simplicity of design, and allowing purposes and spaces to evolve based on user needs. Overall the document advocates for meaningful involvement of both students and staff in the co-creation of new learning environments.

Design journal

R. Sosa

This is a 'workbook' or a journal used to teach design in Engineering and Architecture programs, first year undergraduate. It reinforces key concepts from lectures, defines activities for students, and 'scaffolds' the design journey aiming to be more flexible as the course progresses. this journal has been reviewed after using it at multiple courses, including 3.007 Introduction to Design at Singapore University of Technology and Design

IC - 2022 - Module Guide .pdf

ssuser4a1ad9

This document provides information about the Business Improvement and Creativity module taking place from January to June 2022. It outlines the module coordinator, Dr. Chris Milner, and module team member Judi Karas. It then provides details about the module synopsis and objectives, learning aims and outcomes, assessment, and delivery approach. Students will complete a portfolio and reflective essay analyzing a business improvement framework applied to an organization of their choice. The module uses a blended learning approach including prerecorded lectures and live seminars/workshops.

Why choose DT at FGCS?

NFollad

This document provides information about the Design & Technology (DT) program at Forest Gate Community School. It outlines that DT focuses on planning, designing and creating products for people to use. Students will learn skills like problem solving, designing, making, and using tools and machines. The program will assess students through 50% coursework and 50% exam testing their design skills and knowledge of technical principles. DT can lead to careers in creative and design fields, and students will have access to resources like 3D printers and sewing machines.

Structural systems

tepu msosa

This seminar provides a review of common structural design considerations for building design. It will discuss typical structural systems for foundations, gravity loads, and lateral loads. Attendees will learn about structural coordination issues, requirements for structural inspections, and case studies of various building projects. The seminar aims to help design teams better understand how structural systems relate to overall building design.

Introduction to Engineering and Profession Ethics Lecture3-Introduction to En...

Dr. Khaled Bakro

The document introduces the engineering design process and its basic steps: 1) recognizing a need, 2) defining the problem, 3) researching, 4) conceptualizing, 5) synthesizing, 6) evaluating, 7) optimizing, and 8) presenting. It discusses important considerations like teamwork, scheduling, and sustainability. An example case study is presented on retrofitting an anti-lock braking system for cars to heavier sport utility vehicles. Through computer simulation and testing, a solution is developed and presented that meets performance and cost criteria.

Architectural Professional Practice - Introduction

Galala University

This document provides an overview and summary of a course on professional practice for architecture students. The summary includes: 1) An introduction to the course, including information on the instructor, time/location of lectures, prerequisites, and catalog description. 2) An outline of the course requirements, including attendance, assignments, exams, and evaluation methods. 3) A list of the key learning objectives covering topics like the architect's role, project documentation, ethics, licensing, the building process, contracts, economics/finance, and professional organizations.

Fmp

hwells2101

This document outlines the steps students will take to decide on an area of specialization for their final project. It involves researching different topics, themes, cultures and issues to generate ideas. Students will work individually and in pairs/groups to brainstorm potential research areas and decide on a topic. They will also research techniques relevant to their chosen media format. By the end, students are expected to have a portfolio of research and decided on an area to focus their project.

SEMESTER 1: Introduction to Construction Industry Project 2 Brief - Building ...

University of Nottingham

This document outlines the project requirements for a class on the construction industry. It has two main parts: 1) A group project where students interview professionals from the construction industry like architects, contractors, and engineers. They must create an 8-minute video presentation summarizing their findings. 2) An individual project where each student writes a 6-page magazine article demonstrating their understanding of the construction industry elements covered in the group project. It provides assessment criteria for both the group video presentation and individual magazine article focusing on general understanding, content, and creativity. The goal is for students to develop an understanding of the various roles in the construction industry and how to communicate their findings effectively.

Ic ijan2014 assignment 2

suehwa533

1. The document outlines the project requirements for an introductory course on the construction industry. 2. Students are split into groups and assigned a type of construction professional to interview, such as an architect, contractor, or engineer. They must research the firm, interview an employee, and create an 8-minute video presentation. 3. Additionally, each student must individually write a 6-page magazine article demonstrating their understanding of the group's assigned professional. They will be assessed on content, creativity, and understanding of the construction industry.

Spring 2024 - ARC041 Introduction to Building Construction - Introduction.pdf

Duo-YM&AF-Architecture Education vs Practice Debate-29Sep.pdf

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Similar to Duo-YM&AF-Architecture Education vs Practice Debate-29Sep.pdf

Similar to Duo-YM&AF-Architecture Education vs Practice Debate-29Sep.pdf (20)

More from Yasser Mahgoub

More from Yasser Mahgoub (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Duo-YM&AF-Architecture Education vs Practice Debate-29Sep.pdf