尊敬的 微信汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046239 元 支付宝汇率:1円 ≈ 0.04633元 [退出登录]
SlideShare a Scribd company logo
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
B TECH 8th
SEMESTER
01 1827 CONSTRUCTION PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT
L-T-P : 3-0-0 Credit : 3
Module 2: Value Analysis, Feasibility studies; Economics of project evaluation: Finance, material
and manpower development.
Total number of Lecture: 8
Introduction: The competencies required for developing business cases
comprise a range of skills, including those for:
 facilitation and negotiation
 demand management
 risk management
 value management
 economic, social, environmental and budget analyses, and
 strategic planning.
Project evaluation
Evaluation of building project proposals is a key element of a department's
financial and service delivery planning and in the formulation of capital works
programs. Building projects are initiated where strategies selected through
strategic planning involve building requirements. Planning for assets at this
strategic level involves establishing what assets are required to support service
and output strategies identified in a department's corporate plan and service
delivery strategies. These are compared to existing available assets. Strategies
are developed for acquisition of new building assets and reconfiguration, use,
refurbishment and disposal of existing assets. This process includes
consideration of recurrent cost implications of capital investment.
Asset strategies developed through this process and incorporated in a
department's capital investment strategic plan form the basis from which options
are further developed and evaluated and capital investment programs
formulated. These activities are undertaken as part of the project development,
which includes the project evaluation and program formulation phases in the
capital works management process.
Asset strategic planning, project evaluation and the State Budget process are
key elements in determining building requirements and those building proposals
that provide the best value for money and that can and should progress to
funding approval in the program formulation phase.
The project evaluation phase incorporates the project feasibility and business
case stages and provides a structured approach for undertaking project
feasibility studies to establish preferred options and, where required, develop a
business case that supports service delivery through asset strategies. When asset
strategies include building elements, the business case should establish: a
preferred building solution that meets service delivery needs; the basis for
funding application and inclusion in capital works programs; and the basis for
building performance review in the project review phase of the capital works
management process.
Project feasibility
Project feasibility involves:
 defining the objectives and scope of individual projects;
 identifying and selecting suitable options;
 carrying out project analyses; and
 selecting preferred options.
Project feasibility involves the comparative evaluation of ‘build' and ‘non-build'
scenarios relating to the project and should be undertaken in accordance with
the process. It revisits the asset strategic planning process with input to a
department's capital investment strategic plan, but at a project level.
Defining the objectives and scope of projects
The purpose of the project must be defined in terms of the benefits the project
will provide. These can be expressed as ‘outcomes' (e.g. increased provision of
government services to the region) and as an ‘output' (e.g. build a new facility).
These outcomes and outputs should be drawn from the department's corporate
and capital investment strategic planning processes, which establish linkages
with government priorities and regional strategies. Any project proposal should
include specific information on the functional requirements and how it will
contribute to the department's service delivery strategy.
Identifying and selecting suitable options
Departments should pursue innovative solutions when formulating options for
building projects and should consider option strategies, such as joint ventures,
non-building solutions, outsourcing and private sector involvement. Options
should include suitable options identified through the asset strategic planning
process (e.g. gap analysis may identify potential to meet building requirements
through refurbishment or upgrading of existing buildings). They should always
include the option to take no action.
Building project options may include:
 new building construction;
 extensions to existing buildings;
 major refurbishment (or upgrading) of buildings;
 reconfiguration of existing buildings;
 acquisition of buildings;
 leasing of building space; or
 site acquisition for building purposes.
Project options should, where appropriate, take into account the disposal of
existing buildings and the decommissioning of leased premises. When a number
of location and site options are available, it will be necessary to include these in
project analyses.
Carrying out project analyses
Following identification and preliminary assessments of all reasonable building,
non-building, location and site options, the most suitable options should be
short listed for detailed analysis. The purpose of detailed project analysis is to
ensure best value for money through economic, environmental, social and
budget analyses of all short listed options. The degree of analysis undertaken
should be tailored to appropriately manage risks associated with individual
projects. In undertaking the analysis, departments should give consideration to
departmental priorities, government policies and legislation.
Economic analysis
Techniques used for economic analysis such as Cost/Benefit Analysis and
Cost/Effectiveness Analysis. For building projects, the net economic benefits of
each option are assessed by calculating the Net Present Value (NPV) using the
Cost/Benefit Analysis technique. Cost/Effectiveness Analysis is appropriate for
projects with strong community or social welfare objectives that may be
difficult to value and should only be used when the project and the benefits are
of reasonable significance. NPV is today's value of all future cash inflows and
outflows of a project option. The NPV is the difference between the streams of
costs and benefits of an option, both discounted to a present value by the
application of a discount rate. Discounting takes into account the time value of
money so that options with different cash flows can be compared.
Analysis of the cost of service delivery associated with an option should
consider total asset management and service delivery costs. This will involve
analyses of life cycle costs including capital, recurrent and disposal costs. In
some cases, such as the delivery of health services, the recurrent costs
associated with projects can exceed the capital investment after a relatively
short period of use. The NPV is a key decision criterion used to rank project
options. All other considerations being equal, the project option with the highest
NPV represents the option with the greatest economic benefit. In these cases,
social benefits and other qualitative issues may be important considerations. As
there will always be some degree of uncertainty surrounding the outcome of an
evaluation, the projected outcomes should be tested under different scenarios.
This may be undertaken by determining realistic ranges (i.e. worst to best) for
all key variables. NPV calculations are performed using different combinations
of worst and best case scenarios. These analyses can identify minimum sets of
changes in key assumptions that would alter the ranking of project options.
Techniques include sensitivity analysis, risk analysis and scenario planning.
Sensitivity analysis is used to determine the sensitivity of the NPV to changes in
key project variables. This process enables the identification of variables that
are critical to the robustness of the estimated values. Sensitivity analyses should
be undertaken to establish:
 sensitivity of the options' NPVs to changes in the discount rate; and
 sensitivity of the options' NPVs to changes in at least one key project
variable.
Risk analysis can be used where there are a limited number of key variables.
Major assumptions made in the analysis will assist in identifying risks
associated with the options. For capital building projects, risks may be
associated with the following areas:
 benefits - the areas of exposure or major assumptions associated with the
estimated benefits;
 time, cost and quality - the major factors in selecting either a traditional or a
non-traditional form of project delivery to manage the project specific risks.
Risks may be associated with reliability of cost estimates (including potential
cost exposures) or with management of particularly large projects, and
 social and environmental impacts - assumptions made in estimating the
social and environmental impact of options. Risks may be associated, for
example, with particular local requirements for disaster mitigation strategies,
including preventative measures to safeguard or minimize impact on or of all
new building projects.
Scenario planning may also be used to assess risk associated with project
options if there is a number of assumptions and variables used in the
analysis. Clear statements of assumptions made in analyses and the reasons
for making such assumptions must be given so that decision-makers are fully
informed. For example, if analysis of an option for construction of office
accommodation is undertaken on the assumption that office rents will
increase at more than the rate of inflation, the assumption could be justified
by evidence of market trends including the projected returns and demand for
office space in the particular area. Where necessary, independent expert
assessments should be obtained in order to develop and justify the costs and
demand estimates.
Environmental analysis
As well as its general benefits and its financial and economic performance, a
project should also be assessed as to whether it might have any negative impact
on the environment.
The negative environmental impact of a project normally relates to the
development of the market site itself. If this not undertaken properly and in
conformity with an agreed master plan the development could: increase traffic
congestion in the vicinity of the market site, particularly if the site entry is
poorly located;
 cause flooding to adjacent land, because of increased surface water run-off, a
restricted site outlet or lack of on-site storage; and
 produce glare and noise impact on adjacent land uses if insulation, screening
and planting proposals are not carefully integrated into the development
programme.
Social analysis
Budget analysis
This analysis should identify outlays and revenues over the forward estimates
period for all resource strategies (i.e. human resource, information technology
and asset strategies) and include capital and recurrent outlays, revenues and the
funding source for each project option. The effects each option has on the State
Budget should also be identified, and include consideration of the impact on the
department's capital and recurrent budgets. The impact on other organisations
(such as the impact of any inter-departmental charges) should also be included.
Selecting the preferred option
The short-listed options should be ranked according to the NPV when the
Cost/Benefit Analysis technique has been used. For Cost/Effectiveness
Analysis, the NPV of costs should be used to determine the lowest cost option.
Where the impacts of environmental, social and budget analysis have not been
factored into the economic evaluation, the ranking of options established by the
economic analysis should be adjusted based on a synthesis of these analyses.
This may be undertaken by assessing costs associated with the major
environmental, social and budget impacts to adjust the NPVs to reflect
departmental and Government priorities.
The preferred option, which is the outcome of the project feasibility stage,
contributes to the formulation of capital investment plans and capital works
programs.
Business case
The business case stage involves documentation of the analyses undertaken in
the project feasibility stage. Where required for building projects,
documentation of a business case is undertaken when the project analysis has
arrived at a preferred option that incorporates building elements.
In these cases, the functional requirements justified by the project feasibility and
documented in the business case will form the basis of project delivery and
assist in keeping building projects focused on service delivery outcomes.
A generic outline for business cases
The following generic table of contents has been developed to provide guidance
on the content and requirements for business cases. Departments may choose to
adopt this structure for documentation of business cases.
Table of contents
Executive summary
1 Project background
2 Objectives and scope of project
3 Project options
4 Project analysis
5 Preferred option
6 Recommendations
Attachments
Executive summary
An executive summary should provide an outline of the capital investment
proposal and, consistent with the requirements for project evaluation reports and
it should state:
 whether the project advances government priorities and contributes to
outcomes established through the department's strategic plan;
 if the project forms part of an interdepartmental strategy (such as for co-
location of facilities);
 the impact the project will have on service delivery and departmental
outcomes;
 how the project contributes to outputs and increased productivity;
 what budgetary impact and economic return the project will produce;
 whether options other than the government as owner and operator have been
considered; and
 how the project is to be funded.
Project background
The project background should document:
 earlier planning for service delivery through corporate planning and
development of service delivery and resource strategies, and in particular,
identified needs for capital building elements incorporated in asset strategies;
 any earlier activities relating to project development; and
 an explanation of the process and analyses undertaken in developing the
business case.
The emphasis, here, should be on the major benefits of the project, including the
impact it will have on service delivery outcomes.
Objectives and scope of project
Based on the results of the project feasibility stage of project development, the
purpose of the project must be defined in terms of the benefits the project will
provide. The main issues to be documented relate to:
 current and projected demand for services;
 identification of functional requirements of the building project proposal;
and
 the functional relationship with other infrastructure segments.
Project options
Project options identified and selected in the project feasibility stage should be
documented. The concept of each option including details of joint ventures,
outsourcing and private sector involvement as well as details of the take no
action scenario and both building and nonbuilding solutions should be outlined.
Particular information to be included should relate to:
 meeting functional and service delivery requirements, such as location and
details of space and floor area provisions;
 capital costs including land acquisition, design and construction costs,
furniture and equipment costs, fees and charges, relocation and
commissioning costs and allowances for contingencies;
 recurrent costs including operating costs (for the asset, human resources and
information technology) and maintenance costs;
 associated financial strategies including funding of capital and recurrent
costs; and
 site and other project implications.
Project analysis
This section should summarise the analysis of the building and non-building
options undertaken in the project feasibility stage. It should present findings of
analyses undertaken in the project feasibility stage, including:
 the economic analysis presenting a comparison of the net benefits of each
option and the associated sensitivity and risk analyses;
 the environmental analysis outlining all environmental consequences and the
short-term and long-term environmental effects and mitigation strategies
relating to each option;
 the social analysis outlining significant social issues, impacts, costs or
opportunities associated with each option as well as their impact and
proposed strategies;
 the budget analysis outlining the outlays and revenues for each option over
the forward estimates period and documenting the impact of each option on
the State Budget and other organisations; and
 the synthesis of the above analyses including results of application of
performance criteria reflecting departmental and government priorities.
Preferred option
A summary of the preferred option should be presented along with a statement
outlining the reasons for selecting this option. Where the preferred option
includes a building solution, the summary should describe the concept including
details of any joint ventures, outsourcing and private sector involvement.
Particular information to be summarised should relate to:
 location and details of the building concept, including space and floor area
provisions;
 capital costs including land acquisition, design and construction costs,
furniture and equipment costs, fees and charges, relocation and
commissioning costs, and allowances for contingencies;
 recurrent costs including operating costs (for the asset, human resources and
information technology) and maintenance costs;
 associated financial strategies including funding of capital and recurrent
costs as well as cash flows for each financial year over the three year
forward estimates period (and subsequent years as appropriate);
 site and other project implications; and
 a procurement strategy including delivery and programming aspects.
Recommendations
The recommendations should be introduced by referring to the preferred option,
the reasons for selecting this option and the impact should the project not
proceed. This section should then provide specific recommendations relating to
adoption of the preferred option and make further recommendations as
appropriate to progress the project. Particular recommendations may relate to:
 any site designation or approval processes;
 further considerations required by government committees, such as the
Cabinet Budget Review Committee; and
 Cabinet submissions required such as when the proposal provides for private
sector participation.
Attachments
The extent of information required to support the project will depend on the
level of analysis undertaken and, where appropriate, may be attached to the
business case.

More Related Content

What's hot

Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel TemplateCritical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
SHAZEBALIKHAN1
 
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULINGOR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
Jignesh Kariya
 
Pert and cpm
Pert and cpmPert and cpm
Pert and cpm
Shashank Kapoor
 
Chapter 12(cpm pert)
Chapter 12(cpm pert)Chapter 12(cpm pert)
Chapter 12(cpm pert)
Debanjan15
 
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network AnalysisCritical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
Asif Sultan Razu
 
08 ch06
08 ch0608 ch06
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
SN Panigrahi, PMP
 
Project management techniques
Project management techniquesProject management techniques
Project management techniques
Ragjni Govindaraju
 
PERT
PERTPERT
PERT
PERTPERT
ITFT - Project Management
ITFT - Project ManagementITFT - Project Management
ITFT - Project Management
Pooja
 
Lecture 6
Lecture 6Lecture 6
Lecture 6
Yasir Khan
 
Network Analysis, PERT, CPM
Network Analysis, PERT, CPMNetwork Analysis, PERT, CPM
Network Analysis, PERT, CPM
keerthi pinipe
 
Seminar on pert
Seminar on pertSeminar on pert
Seminar on pert
Santosh Kumari
 
Pert & Cpm
Pert & CpmPert & Cpm
Pert & Cpm
Vikram Thadeshvar
 
FINAL REPORT
FINAL REPORTFINAL REPORT
FINAL REPORT
Divya Tadi
 
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
Pantho Sarker
 
Project management & Network analysis
Project management & Network analysisProject management & Network analysis
Project management & Network analysis
Harinadh Karimikonda
 
Project management - CPM & PERT
Project management   - CPM & PERTProject management   - CPM & PERT
Project management - CPM & PERT
Dr. Varaprasada Rao Manda
 
Pert
PertPert
Pert
corvinno
 

What's hot (20)

Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel TemplateCritical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
Critical Path Explained With 7 Q&As and a Free Excel Template
 
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULINGOR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
OR PERT CPM AND JOB SCHEDULING
 
Pert and cpm
Pert and cpmPert and cpm
Pert and cpm
 
Chapter 12(cpm pert)
Chapter 12(cpm pert)Chapter 12(cpm pert)
Chapter 12(cpm pert)
 
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network AnalysisCritical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
Critical Path Method (CPM) & Network Analysis
 
08 ch06
08 ch0608 ch06
08 ch06
 
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
#Project Scheduling - Network Diagrams : PERT & CPM# By SN Panigrahi
 
Project management techniques
Project management techniquesProject management techniques
Project management techniques
 
PERT
PERTPERT
PERT
 
PERT
PERTPERT
PERT
 
ITFT - Project Management
ITFT - Project ManagementITFT - Project Management
ITFT - Project Management
 
Lecture 6
Lecture 6Lecture 6
Lecture 6
 
Network Analysis, PERT, CPM
Network Analysis, PERT, CPMNetwork Analysis, PERT, CPM
Network Analysis, PERT, CPM
 
Seminar on pert
Seminar on pertSeminar on pert
Seminar on pert
 
Pert & Cpm
Pert & CpmPert & Cpm
Pert & Cpm
 
FINAL REPORT
FINAL REPORTFINAL REPORT
FINAL REPORT
 
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
“Application of the Program Evaluation Review and Technique
 
Project management & Network analysis
Project management & Network analysisProject management & Network analysis
Project management & Network analysis
 
Project management - CPM & PERT
Project management   - CPM & PERTProject management   - CPM & PERT
Project management - CPM & PERT
 
Pert
PertPert
Pert
 

Similar to Economics of project evaluation cpm module2

Project mgt
Project mgtProject mgt
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
ssuserad21d8
 
Cost Estimation method in engineering economics
Cost Estimation method in engineering economicsCost Estimation method in engineering economics
Cost Estimation method in engineering economics
Suman922623
 
EstimatingGuidelines.pdf
EstimatingGuidelines.pdfEstimatingGuidelines.pdf
EstimatingGuidelines.pdf
Ictsol
 
Cost management
Cost managementCost management
Cost management
shkadry
 
Feasibility study
Feasibility studyFeasibility study
Feasibility study
BABYANA CONSTRUCTION SDN BHD
 
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptxPUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
kipkorirkoech5
 
Cost benefit analysis of resources
Cost benefit analysis of resourcesCost benefit analysis of resources
Cost benefit analysis of resources
Al Jubaer
 
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docxW4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
celenarouzie
 
Constructiion cost estimating 2017
Constructiion cost estimating 2017Constructiion cost estimating 2017
Constructiion cost estimating 2017
Peter Cholakis
 
Project appraisal
Project appraisalProject appraisal
Project appraisal
Gotham Ram
 
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
adabotor7
 
133 whole life costing
133 whole life costing133 whole life costing
133 whole life costing
Dr Fereidoun Dejahang
 
Project formulation and appraisal
Project formulation and appraisalProject formulation and appraisal
Project formulation and appraisal
AmandaBvera
 
Total-Project-Cost.pptx
Total-Project-Cost.pptxTotal-Project-Cost.pptx
Total-Project-Cost.pptx
MaryqueenieVillaflor
 
Module 2.pdf
Module 2.pdfModule 2.pdf
Module 2.pdf
SaffanAhmed1
 
project cost management.pptx
project cost management.pptxproject cost management.pptx
project cost management.pptx
InayatSheikh1
 
Pm chapter 2
Pm chapter 2Pm chapter 2
Pm chapter 2
Golam Bitonsir
 
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.pptcon_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
sheryl90
 
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.pptcon_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
sheryl90
 

Similar to Economics of project evaluation cpm module2 (20)

Project mgt
Project mgtProject mgt
Project mgt
 
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
46R-11 Skills & Knowledge of Cost Estimators.pdf
 
Cost Estimation method in engineering economics
Cost Estimation method in engineering economicsCost Estimation method in engineering economics
Cost Estimation method in engineering economics
 
EstimatingGuidelines.pdf
EstimatingGuidelines.pdfEstimatingGuidelines.pdf
EstimatingGuidelines.pdf
 
Cost management
Cost managementCost management
Cost management
 
Feasibility study
Feasibility studyFeasibility study
Feasibility study
 
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptxPUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT-Module.pptx
 
Cost benefit analysis of resources
Cost benefit analysis of resourcesCost benefit analysis of resources
Cost benefit analysis of resources
 
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docxW4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
W4N1 Cost Management OverviewCost management is a critical comp.docx
 
Constructiion cost estimating 2017
Constructiion cost estimating 2017Constructiion cost estimating 2017
Constructiion cost estimating 2017
 
Project appraisal
Project appraisalProject appraisal
Project appraisal
 
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
1 ch 1 Project CM.pptx ggggggggggggggggg
 
133 whole life costing
133 whole life costing133 whole life costing
133 whole life costing
 
Project formulation and appraisal
Project formulation and appraisalProject formulation and appraisal
Project formulation and appraisal
 
Total-Project-Cost.pptx
Total-Project-Cost.pptxTotal-Project-Cost.pptx
Total-Project-Cost.pptx
 
Module 2.pdf
Module 2.pdfModule 2.pdf
Module 2.pdf
 
project cost management.pptx
project cost management.pptxproject cost management.pptx
project cost management.pptx
 
Pm chapter 2
Pm chapter 2Pm chapter 2
Pm chapter 2
 
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.pptcon_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
 
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.pptcon_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
con_mangt-lec4-project_costppt.ppt
 

More from ahsanrabbani

Site layout cpm module4
Site layout cpm module4Site layout cpm module4
Site layout cpm module4
ahsanrabbani
 
Assignment iii cpm
Assignment iii cpmAssignment iii cpm
Assignment iii cpm
ahsanrabbani
 
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
ahsanrabbani
 
Welded plate girder
Welded plate girderWelded plate girder
Welded plate girder
ahsanrabbani
 
Column splices design
Column splices designColumn splices design
Column splices design
ahsanrabbani
 
Beam column design
Beam column designBeam column design
Beam column design
ahsanrabbani
 
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
ahsanrabbani
 
Summer trhrg
Summer trhrgSummer trhrg
Summer trhrg
ahsanrabbani
 
Ship in
Ship inShip in
Ship in
ahsanrabbani
 
Notification jr fellow
Notification jr fellowNotification jr fellow
Notification jr fellow
ahsanrabbani
 
Mba fulltime semester i
Mba fulltime   semester iMba fulltime   semester i
Mba fulltime semester i
ahsanrabbani
 
Mba adv-(2011-12)
Mba adv-(2011-12)Mba adv-(2011-12)
Mba adv-(2011-12)
ahsanrabbani
 
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
ahsanrabbani
 
Form1
Form1Form1
Contract lecturers various_depts
Contract lecturers various_deptsContract lecturers various_depts
Contract lecturers various_depts
ahsanrabbani
 
Ballia
BalliaBallia
Ballia
ahsanrabbani
 
Agr test41
Agr test41Agr test41
Agr test41
ahsanrabbani
 
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
ahsanrabbani
 
Adv2011
Adv2011Adv2011
Adv2011
ahsanrabbani
 
33 37 pukird, s
33 37 pukird, s33 37 pukird, s
33 37 pukird, s
ahsanrabbani
 

More from ahsanrabbani (20)

Site layout cpm module4
Site layout cpm module4Site layout cpm module4
Site layout cpm module4
 
Assignment iii cpm
Assignment iii cpmAssignment iii cpm
Assignment iii cpm
 
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
Economics of project evaluation for reference cpm module2
 
Welded plate girder
Welded plate girderWelded plate girder
Welded plate girder
 
Column splices design
Column splices designColumn splices design
Column splices design
 
Beam column design
Beam column designBeam column design
Beam column design
 
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
Design of steel structure as per is 800(2007)
 
Summer trhrg
Summer trhrgSummer trhrg
Summer trhrg
 
Ship in
Ship inShip in
Ship in
 
Notification jr fellow
Notification jr fellowNotification jr fellow
Notification jr fellow
 
Mba fulltime semester i
Mba fulltime   semester iMba fulltime   semester i
Mba fulltime semester i
 
Mba adv-(2011-12)
Mba adv-(2011-12)Mba adv-(2011-12)
Mba adv-(2011-12)
 
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
Infor bullet-mba-2011-12
 
Form1
Form1Form1
Form1
 
Contract lecturers various_depts
Contract lecturers various_deptsContract lecturers various_depts
Contract lecturers various_depts
 
Ballia
BalliaBallia
Ballia
 
Agr test41
Agr test41Agr test41
Agr test41
 
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
Advertisement 3rd conclave_2010
 
Adv2011
Adv2011Adv2011
Adv2011
 
33 37 pukird, s
33 37 pukird, s33 37 pukird, s
33 37 pukird, s
 

Recently uploaded

一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
nonods
 
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
DharmaBanothu
 
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdfMy Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
Geoffrey Wardle. MSc. MSc. Snr.MAIAA
 
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptxLateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
DebendraDevKhanal1
 
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUESAN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
drshikhapandey2022
 
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls ChennaiCall Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
paraasingh12 #V08
 
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdfButterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
Lubi Valves
 
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineeringTENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
SnehalChavan75
 
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Banerescorts
 
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdfData Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdfCovid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdfCSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
Ismail Sultan
 
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sdeIntuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
ShivangMishra54
 
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdf
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdfCricket management system ptoject report.pdf
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdfSri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Balvir Singh
 
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
dulbh kashyap
 
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
Poonam Singh
 
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
sexytaniya455
 
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call GirlCall Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
sapna sharmap11
 
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
hotchicksescort
 

Recently uploaded (20)

一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(psu学位证书)美国匹兹堡州立大学毕业证如何办理
 
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
An In-Depth Exploration of Natural Language Processing: Evolution, Applicatio...
 
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdfMy Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
My Airframe Metallic Design Capability Studies..pdf
 
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptxLateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
Lateral load-resisting systems in buildings.pptx
 
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUESAN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
AN INTRODUCTION OF AI & SEARCHING TECHIQUES
 
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls ChennaiCall Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
Call Girls Chennai +91-8824825030 Vip Call Girls Chennai
 
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdfButterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
Butterfly Valves Manufacturer (LBF Series).pdf
 
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineeringTENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
TENDERS and Contracts basic syllabus for engineering
 
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
Hot Call Girls In Bangalore ✔ 9079923931 ✔ Hi I Am Divya Vip Call Girl Servic...
 
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdfData Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
Data Communication and Computer Networks Management System Project Report.pdf
 
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdfCovid Management System Project Report.pdf
Covid Management System Project Report.pdf
 
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdfCSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
CSP_Study - Notes (Paul McNeill) 2017.pdf
 
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sdeIntuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
Intuit CRAFT demonstration presentation for sde
 
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdf
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdfCricket management system ptoject report.pdf
Cricket management system ptoject report.pdf
 
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdfSri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji - Bandi Chor Guru.pdf
 
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
🚺ANJALI MEHTA High Profile Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top C...
 
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
Call Girls Madurai 8824825030 Escort In Madurai service 24X7
 
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
Call Girls Nagpur 8824825030 Escort In Nagpur service 24X7
 
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call GirlCall Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
Call Girls Goa (india) ☎️ +91-7426014248 Goa Call Girl
 
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
❣Unsatisfied Bhabhi Call Girls Surat 💯Call Us 🔝 7014168258 🔝💃Independent Sura...
 

Economics of project evaluation cpm module2

  • 1. DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING B TECH 8th SEMESTER 01 1827 CONSTRUCTION PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT L-T-P : 3-0-0 Credit : 3 Module 2: Value Analysis, Feasibility studies; Economics of project evaluation: Finance, material and manpower development. Total number of Lecture: 8 Introduction: The competencies required for developing business cases comprise a range of skills, including those for:  facilitation and negotiation  demand management  risk management  value management  economic, social, environmental and budget analyses, and  strategic planning. Project evaluation Evaluation of building project proposals is a key element of a department's financial and service delivery planning and in the formulation of capital works programs. Building projects are initiated where strategies selected through strategic planning involve building requirements. Planning for assets at this strategic level involves establishing what assets are required to support service and output strategies identified in a department's corporate plan and service delivery strategies. These are compared to existing available assets. Strategies are developed for acquisition of new building assets and reconfiguration, use, refurbishment and disposal of existing assets. This process includes consideration of recurrent cost implications of capital investment. Asset strategies developed through this process and incorporated in a department's capital investment strategic plan form the basis from which options are further developed and evaluated and capital investment programs formulated. These activities are undertaken as part of the project development, which includes the project evaluation and program formulation phases in the capital works management process. Asset strategic planning, project evaluation and the State Budget process are key elements in determining building requirements and those building proposals that provide the best value for money and that can and should progress to funding approval in the program formulation phase.
  • 2. The project evaluation phase incorporates the project feasibility and business case stages and provides a structured approach for undertaking project feasibility studies to establish preferred options and, where required, develop a business case that supports service delivery through asset strategies. When asset strategies include building elements, the business case should establish: a preferred building solution that meets service delivery needs; the basis for funding application and inclusion in capital works programs; and the basis for building performance review in the project review phase of the capital works management process. Project feasibility Project feasibility involves:  defining the objectives and scope of individual projects;  identifying and selecting suitable options;  carrying out project analyses; and  selecting preferred options. Project feasibility involves the comparative evaluation of ‘build' and ‘non-build' scenarios relating to the project and should be undertaken in accordance with the process. It revisits the asset strategic planning process with input to a department's capital investment strategic plan, but at a project level. Defining the objectives and scope of projects The purpose of the project must be defined in terms of the benefits the project will provide. These can be expressed as ‘outcomes' (e.g. increased provision of government services to the region) and as an ‘output' (e.g. build a new facility). These outcomes and outputs should be drawn from the department's corporate and capital investment strategic planning processes, which establish linkages with government priorities and regional strategies. Any project proposal should include specific information on the functional requirements and how it will contribute to the department's service delivery strategy. Identifying and selecting suitable options Departments should pursue innovative solutions when formulating options for building projects and should consider option strategies, such as joint ventures, non-building solutions, outsourcing and private sector involvement. Options should include suitable options identified through the asset strategic planning process (e.g. gap analysis may identify potential to meet building requirements through refurbishment or upgrading of existing buildings). They should always include the option to take no action. Building project options may include:  new building construction;
  • 3.  extensions to existing buildings;  major refurbishment (or upgrading) of buildings;  reconfiguration of existing buildings;  acquisition of buildings;  leasing of building space; or  site acquisition for building purposes. Project options should, where appropriate, take into account the disposal of existing buildings and the decommissioning of leased premises. When a number of location and site options are available, it will be necessary to include these in project analyses. Carrying out project analyses Following identification and preliminary assessments of all reasonable building, non-building, location and site options, the most suitable options should be short listed for detailed analysis. The purpose of detailed project analysis is to ensure best value for money through economic, environmental, social and budget analyses of all short listed options. The degree of analysis undertaken should be tailored to appropriately manage risks associated with individual projects. In undertaking the analysis, departments should give consideration to departmental priorities, government policies and legislation. Economic analysis Techniques used for economic analysis such as Cost/Benefit Analysis and Cost/Effectiveness Analysis. For building projects, the net economic benefits of each option are assessed by calculating the Net Present Value (NPV) using the Cost/Benefit Analysis technique. Cost/Effectiveness Analysis is appropriate for projects with strong community or social welfare objectives that may be difficult to value and should only be used when the project and the benefits are of reasonable significance. NPV is today's value of all future cash inflows and outflows of a project option. The NPV is the difference between the streams of costs and benefits of an option, both discounted to a present value by the application of a discount rate. Discounting takes into account the time value of money so that options with different cash flows can be compared. Analysis of the cost of service delivery associated with an option should consider total asset management and service delivery costs. This will involve analyses of life cycle costs including capital, recurrent and disposal costs. In some cases, such as the delivery of health services, the recurrent costs associated with projects can exceed the capital investment after a relatively short period of use. The NPV is a key decision criterion used to rank project options. All other considerations being equal, the project option with the highest NPV represents the option with the greatest economic benefit. In these cases,
  • 4. social benefits and other qualitative issues may be important considerations. As there will always be some degree of uncertainty surrounding the outcome of an evaluation, the projected outcomes should be tested under different scenarios. This may be undertaken by determining realistic ranges (i.e. worst to best) for all key variables. NPV calculations are performed using different combinations of worst and best case scenarios. These analyses can identify minimum sets of changes in key assumptions that would alter the ranking of project options. Techniques include sensitivity analysis, risk analysis and scenario planning. Sensitivity analysis is used to determine the sensitivity of the NPV to changes in key project variables. This process enables the identification of variables that are critical to the robustness of the estimated values. Sensitivity analyses should be undertaken to establish:  sensitivity of the options' NPVs to changes in the discount rate; and  sensitivity of the options' NPVs to changes in at least one key project variable. Risk analysis can be used where there are a limited number of key variables. Major assumptions made in the analysis will assist in identifying risks associated with the options. For capital building projects, risks may be associated with the following areas:  benefits - the areas of exposure or major assumptions associated with the estimated benefits;  time, cost and quality - the major factors in selecting either a traditional or a non-traditional form of project delivery to manage the project specific risks. Risks may be associated with reliability of cost estimates (including potential cost exposures) or with management of particularly large projects, and  social and environmental impacts - assumptions made in estimating the social and environmental impact of options. Risks may be associated, for example, with particular local requirements for disaster mitigation strategies, including preventative measures to safeguard or minimize impact on or of all new building projects. Scenario planning may also be used to assess risk associated with project options if there is a number of assumptions and variables used in the analysis. Clear statements of assumptions made in analyses and the reasons for making such assumptions must be given so that decision-makers are fully informed. For example, if analysis of an option for construction of office accommodation is undertaken on the assumption that office rents will increase at more than the rate of inflation, the assumption could be justified by evidence of market trends including the projected returns and demand for office space in the particular area. Where necessary, independent expert assessments should be obtained in order to develop and justify the costs and demand estimates. Environmental analysis
  • 5. As well as its general benefits and its financial and economic performance, a project should also be assessed as to whether it might have any negative impact on the environment. The negative environmental impact of a project normally relates to the development of the market site itself. If this not undertaken properly and in conformity with an agreed master plan the development could: increase traffic congestion in the vicinity of the market site, particularly if the site entry is poorly located;  cause flooding to adjacent land, because of increased surface water run-off, a restricted site outlet or lack of on-site storage; and  produce glare and noise impact on adjacent land uses if insulation, screening and planting proposals are not carefully integrated into the development programme. Social analysis Budget analysis This analysis should identify outlays and revenues over the forward estimates period for all resource strategies (i.e. human resource, information technology and asset strategies) and include capital and recurrent outlays, revenues and the funding source for each project option. The effects each option has on the State Budget should also be identified, and include consideration of the impact on the department's capital and recurrent budgets. The impact on other organisations (such as the impact of any inter-departmental charges) should also be included. Selecting the preferred option The short-listed options should be ranked according to the NPV when the Cost/Benefit Analysis technique has been used. For Cost/Effectiveness Analysis, the NPV of costs should be used to determine the lowest cost option. Where the impacts of environmental, social and budget analysis have not been factored into the economic evaluation, the ranking of options established by the economic analysis should be adjusted based on a synthesis of these analyses. This may be undertaken by assessing costs associated with the major environmental, social and budget impacts to adjust the NPVs to reflect departmental and Government priorities. The preferred option, which is the outcome of the project feasibility stage, contributes to the formulation of capital investment plans and capital works programs. Business case
  • 6. The business case stage involves documentation of the analyses undertaken in the project feasibility stage. Where required for building projects, documentation of a business case is undertaken when the project analysis has arrived at a preferred option that incorporates building elements. In these cases, the functional requirements justified by the project feasibility and documented in the business case will form the basis of project delivery and assist in keeping building projects focused on service delivery outcomes. A generic outline for business cases The following generic table of contents has been developed to provide guidance on the content and requirements for business cases. Departments may choose to adopt this structure for documentation of business cases. Table of contents Executive summary 1 Project background 2 Objectives and scope of project 3 Project options 4 Project analysis 5 Preferred option 6 Recommendations Attachments Executive summary An executive summary should provide an outline of the capital investment proposal and, consistent with the requirements for project evaluation reports and it should state:  whether the project advances government priorities and contributes to outcomes established through the department's strategic plan;  if the project forms part of an interdepartmental strategy (such as for co- location of facilities);  the impact the project will have on service delivery and departmental outcomes;  how the project contributes to outputs and increased productivity;  what budgetary impact and economic return the project will produce;  whether options other than the government as owner and operator have been considered; and  how the project is to be funded. Project background The project background should document:
  • 7.  earlier planning for service delivery through corporate planning and development of service delivery and resource strategies, and in particular, identified needs for capital building elements incorporated in asset strategies;  any earlier activities relating to project development; and  an explanation of the process and analyses undertaken in developing the business case. The emphasis, here, should be on the major benefits of the project, including the impact it will have on service delivery outcomes. Objectives and scope of project Based on the results of the project feasibility stage of project development, the purpose of the project must be defined in terms of the benefits the project will provide. The main issues to be documented relate to:  current and projected demand for services;  identification of functional requirements of the building project proposal; and  the functional relationship with other infrastructure segments. Project options Project options identified and selected in the project feasibility stage should be documented. The concept of each option including details of joint ventures, outsourcing and private sector involvement as well as details of the take no action scenario and both building and nonbuilding solutions should be outlined. Particular information to be included should relate to:  meeting functional and service delivery requirements, such as location and details of space and floor area provisions;  capital costs including land acquisition, design and construction costs, furniture and equipment costs, fees and charges, relocation and commissioning costs and allowances for contingencies;  recurrent costs including operating costs (for the asset, human resources and information technology) and maintenance costs;  associated financial strategies including funding of capital and recurrent costs; and  site and other project implications. Project analysis This section should summarise the analysis of the building and non-building options undertaken in the project feasibility stage. It should present findings of analyses undertaken in the project feasibility stage, including:  the economic analysis presenting a comparison of the net benefits of each option and the associated sensitivity and risk analyses;
  • 8.  the environmental analysis outlining all environmental consequences and the short-term and long-term environmental effects and mitigation strategies relating to each option;  the social analysis outlining significant social issues, impacts, costs or opportunities associated with each option as well as their impact and proposed strategies;  the budget analysis outlining the outlays and revenues for each option over the forward estimates period and documenting the impact of each option on the State Budget and other organisations; and  the synthesis of the above analyses including results of application of performance criteria reflecting departmental and government priorities. Preferred option A summary of the preferred option should be presented along with a statement outlining the reasons for selecting this option. Where the preferred option includes a building solution, the summary should describe the concept including details of any joint ventures, outsourcing and private sector involvement. Particular information to be summarised should relate to:  location and details of the building concept, including space and floor area provisions;  capital costs including land acquisition, design and construction costs, furniture and equipment costs, fees and charges, relocation and commissioning costs, and allowances for contingencies;  recurrent costs including operating costs (for the asset, human resources and information technology) and maintenance costs;  associated financial strategies including funding of capital and recurrent costs as well as cash flows for each financial year over the three year forward estimates period (and subsequent years as appropriate);  site and other project implications; and  a procurement strategy including delivery and programming aspects. Recommendations The recommendations should be introduced by referring to the preferred option, the reasons for selecting this option and the impact should the project not proceed. This section should then provide specific recommendations relating to adoption of the preferred option and make further recommendations as appropriate to progress the project. Particular recommendations may relate to:  any site designation or approval processes;  further considerations required by government committees, such as the Cabinet Budget Review Committee; and  Cabinet submissions required such as when the proposal provides for private sector participation. Attachments
  • 9. The extent of information required to support the project will depend on the level of analysis undertaken and, where appropriate, may be attached to the business case.
  翻译: