尊敬的 微信汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046166 元 支付宝汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046257元 [退出登录]
SlideShare a Scribd company logo
A Radical New Understanding
of the Housing Bubble
and the Financial Crisis
Presented by Kevin Erdmann
The Housing Bubble
So obvious, the premise didn’t need to be confirmed.
There were never too many homes.
NYC
LA
Boston
San Fran.
San Diego
San Jose
$0
$200,000
$400,000
$600,000
$800,000
$1,000,000
Median Home Rent and Price
50 Largest MSAs
1Q 1991 1Q 2007 1Q 2015
MedianHomePrice
Median Annual Rent
A handful of cities have
become very expensive
to live in – for both
renters and owners.
The housing bubble was
an American refugee
crisis.
Americans were
building new homes in
order to reduce their
housing expenses.
-2.0%
-1.0%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013
Rate of Net Domestic Migration
Closed Access Cities Contagion Cities
Before 2008: Housing markets were driven by supply.
All prices increased.
After 2008: Housing markets were driven by a credit shock.
Low tier prices collapsed.
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
2.25
2.50
Seattle
Quintile 1 Quintile 2 Quintile 3 Quintile 4 Quintile 5
Zip codes, in quintiles by median home price. Jan. 2000 = 1
Supply Driven Migration Event Credit Shock
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
2.25
2.50
Atlanta
Quintile 1 Quintile 2 Quintile 3 Quintile 4 Quintile 5
Zip codes, in quintiles by median home price. Jan. 2000 = 1
Credit ShockSupply Driven Migration Event
The rise of low-tier home prices in high priced cities had little
to do with lending to households with low incomes.
It was more likely a product of our highly regressive income
tax subsidies to homeownership, which cause price/rent ratios
to rise as home prices rise, up to a given price level, where they
level off.
Before 2008: Housing markets were driven by aspirational
households buying into expensive cities and other households
moving to cheaper cities to reduce costs.
After 2008: Public focused on preventing households with
lower incomes from over-buying. This had little to do with the
bubble and left the core problems unaddressed.
Family income quintiles and deciles
Before 2008: Rates of homeownership were within long-term
norms, when adjusted demographically.
After 2008: Homeownership among young and less affluent
households has declined. Homeownership in 2018 is much
more sensitive to age and income than it was in 1995 or 2005,
and homeownership rates are well below any modern norms.
Family income quintiles and deciles
In 2008, Federal regulators
acted as if there was a credit
problem when we had a supply
problem.
This cut home prices
significantly, devastated
homeowners’ equity, and
locked young, first-time, and
working class buyers out of the
market.
For those families, today,
homeownership is a free lunch,
if they can find a way to do it.
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
1979-03
1981-03
1983-03
1985-03
1987-03
1989-03
1991-03
1993-03
1995-03
1997-03
1999-03
2001-03
2003-03
2005-03
2007-03
2009-03
2011-03
2013-03
2015-03
2017-03
Mortgage Affordability vs. Rent Affordability
Mortgage Affordability
Rent Affordability
Inflation & Cost Adjusted Mortgage Affordability
Credit Shock = Unprecedented Affordability
Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation
Housing, especially at the low end, is greatly undervalued.
Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation
Housing, especially at the low end, is greatly undervalued...And obstacles to
real investment – through local building codes and national lending policies –
are pushing down real long term interest rates.
Building more homes would solve the “safe asset shortage” problem.
Investor Returns
vs Owner Returns
Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation
Monetary inflation is perpetually overestimated, creating overly hawkish
monetary policy.
Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation
• We are in a boom-bust economic regime. This is blamed on demand (credit
and money), but it is the result of structural obstacles to supply – most
notably residence in economically dynamic cities.
• This leads to hawkish monetary policy that is creating cyclical risk.
• Real estate, and especially low-end real estate, appears to be more volatile
and risky than previously thought. But, real estate volatility was due to a
one-time negative demand shock that cannot be repeated. In that case, past
volatility points to future stability and reversion to the mean.
• Carefully chosen positions in real estate, lending, and homebuilding markets
can provide both speculative and defensive opportunities for asset
management, even though cyclical risks remain.

More Related Content

What's hot

The Financial Crisis- paper
The Financial Crisis- paperThe Financial Crisis- paper
The Financial Crisis- paper
Philippe De Smit
 
Global Financial Crisis 2008
Global Financial Crisis 2008Global Financial Crisis 2008
Global Financial Crisis 2008
krishnakantjalan
 
Global financial crisis
Global financial crisisGlobal financial crisis
Global financial crisis
Arindam Samanta
 
Macroeconomics of china
Macroeconomics of chinaMacroeconomics of china
Macroeconomics of china
Masoom Modh
 
Subprime crisis
Subprime crisis Subprime crisis
Subprime crisis
mohammedalimiya
 
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
Mohit Rajput
 
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
Ashish Chouksey
 
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
Karim ISSAAD
 
Global financial crisis
Global financial crisisGlobal financial crisis
Global financial crisis
nabila km
 
Economy of chile
Economy of chileEconomy of chile
Economy of chile
thezorex
 
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
Bipin Banerjee D M
 
The National Debt
The National DebtThe National Debt
The National Debt
MrRed
 
Global Financial crisis 2008
Global Financial crisis 2008Global Financial crisis 2008
Global Financial crisis 2008
Mominul Haque bhuiyan
 
Asian crises 1997
Asian crises 1997Asian crises 1997
Asian crises 1997
Hitendrasinh Zala
 
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
Angelica Joyce Zamora
 
Fiannacial intermediation
Fiannacial intermediationFiannacial intermediation
Fiannacial intermediation
StudsPlanet.com
 
Asian Financial Crisis
Asian Financial CrisisAsian Financial Crisis
Asian Financial Crisis
Eliel Daang
 
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and DeflationAS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
tutor2u
 
India and the global financial crisis
India and the global financial crisisIndia and the global financial crisis
India and the global financial crisis
Charu Rastogi
 
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
Krutika Panari
 

What's hot (20)

The Financial Crisis- paper
The Financial Crisis- paperThe Financial Crisis- paper
The Financial Crisis- paper
 
Global Financial Crisis 2008
Global Financial Crisis 2008Global Financial Crisis 2008
Global Financial Crisis 2008
 
Global financial crisis
Global financial crisisGlobal financial crisis
Global financial crisis
 
Macroeconomics of china
Macroeconomics of chinaMacroeconomics of china
Macroeconomics of china
 
Subprime crisis
Subprime crisis Subprime crisis
Subprime crisis
 
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
Presentation - Global financial crisis 2008
 
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
Argentine Economic Crisis (1999-2002)
 
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
LE PNRU DE PERPIGNAN : Le remède efficace à la crise urbaine ?
 
Global financial crisis
Global financial crisisGlobal financial crisis
Global financial crisis
 
Economy of chile
Economy of chileEconomy of chile
Economy of chile
 
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
Global Financial Crisis 2007-08
 
The National Debt
The National DebtThe National Debt
The National Debt
 
Global Financial crisis 2008
Global Financial crisis 2008Global Financial crisis 2008
Global Financial crisis 2008
 
Asian crises 1997
Asian crises 1997Asian crises 1997
Asian crises 1997
 
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
Global Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009)
 
Fiannacial intermediation
Fiannacial intermediationFiannacial intermediation
Fiannacial intermediation
 
Asian Financial Crisis
Asian Financial CrisisAsian Financial Crisis
Asian Financial Crisis
 
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and DeflationAS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
 
India and the global financial crisis
India and the global financial crisisIndia and the global financial crisis
India and the global financial crisis
 
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
Causes of the 1997 South East Asian Financial Crises & its Impact on the Fina...
 

Similar to The Housing Bubble and Financial Crisis: A New View

Slides with Audio
Slides with AudioSlides with Audio
Slides with Audio
Kevin Erdmann
 
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docxTHE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
rtodd33
 
Senior Project: Research Paper
Senior Project: Research PaperSenior Project: Research Paper
Senior Project: Research Paper
Brian_Elliott
 
Analysis of property bubble
Analysis of property bubbleAnalysis of property bubble
Analysis of property bubble
Chia Yuen Woo
 
HOUSING.pptx
HOUSING.pptxHOUSING.pptx
HOUSING.pptx
K Jagannath
 
State of the National Apartment Market
State of the National Apartment MarketState of the National Apartment Market
State of the National Apartment Market
Ryan Slack
 
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
BBCResearch
 
Sub prime crisis
Sub prime crisisSub prime crisis
Sub prime crisis
Sahil Agarwal
 
Mortgage Mess Perspective From January 2009
Mortgage Mess   Perspective From January 2009Mortgage Mess   Perspective From January 2009
Mortgage Mess Perspective From January 2009
Elton and Associates
 
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW PresentationHAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
HAR Communications
 
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
LJ Gilland Real Estate Pty Ltd
 
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
Missouri Association of REALTORS
 
Understanding the Current US Recession
Understanding the Current US RecessionUnderstanding the Current US Recession
Understanding the Current US Recession
Shiva Pillai
 
October Realtor Report
October Realtor ReportOctober Realtor Report
Newsletter Fall 2008
Newsletter Fall 2008Newsletter Fall 2008
Newsletter Fall 2008
Dan Flanagan
 
Marketinsights housing
Marketinsights housingMarketinsights housing
Marketinsights housing
Clint Hammond
 
The subprime mortgage crisis 1
The subprime mortgage crisis 1The subprime mortgage crisis 1
The subprime mortgage crisis 1
dosint
 
#Nyinequality
#Nyinequality#Nyinequality
#Nyinequality
strongforall
 
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economyThe Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
NITINPATHAK75
 
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New EconomyHow to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
McGraw-Hill Professional
 

Similar to The Housing Bubble and Financial Crisis: A New View (20)

Slides with Audio
Slides with AudioSlides with Audio
Slides with Audio
 
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docxTHE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
THE HOUSING MARKETGreat RecessionMortgage collapseHigh i.docx
 
Senior Project: Research Paper
Senior Project: Research PaperSenior Project: Research Paper
Senior Project: Research Paper
 
Analysis of property bubble
Analysis of property bubbleAnalysis of property bubble
Analysis of property bubble
 
HOUSING.pptx
HOUSING.pptxHOUSING.pptx
HOUSING.pptx
 
State of the National Apartment Market
State of the National Apartment MarketState of the National Apartment Market
State of the National Apartment Market
 
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
Affordable Housing: Have We Made a Dent?
 
Sub prime crisis
Sub prime crisisSub prime crisis
Sub prime crisis
 
Mortgage Mess Perspective From January 2009
Mortgage Mess   Perspective From January 2009Mortgage Mess   Perspective From January 2009
Mortgage Mess Perspective From January 2009
 
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW PresentationHAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
HAR Chair Vicki Fullerton - Greater NW Presentation
 
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
-housing-accessibility-for-first-home-buyers #2017
 
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
Jed Smith (Sept. 2008)
 
Understanding the Current US Recession
Understanding the Current US RecessionUnderstanding the Current US Recession
Understanding the Current US Recession
 
October Realtor Report
October Realtor ReportOctober Realtor Report
October Realtor Report
 
Newsletter Fall 2008
Newsletter Fall 2008Newsletter Fall 2008
Newsletter Fall 2008
 
Marketinsights housing
Marketinsights housingMarketinsights housing
Marketinsights housing
 
The subprime mortgage crisis 1
The subprime mortgage crisis 1The subprime mortgage crisis 1
The subprime mortgage crisis 1
 
#Nyinequality
#Nyinequality#Nyinequality
#Nyinequality
 
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economyThe Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
The Crisis of 2008 that hit global economy
 
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New EconomyHow to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
How to Make Money in Real Estate in the New Economy
 

Recently uploaded

Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home DeliveryIndian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
hanshkumar9870
 
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
Henry Tapper
 
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdfDalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Henry Tapper
 
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward SlidesSingapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
International Federation of Accountants
 
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
priya$L14
 
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
khansayyad1256
 
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance PaymentCall Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
prijesh mathew
 
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
eeqcxun
 
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
rosankumar564363
 
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update SlidesSingapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
International Federation of Accountants
 
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of MoneyApplication Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
vineetabhati1
 
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your DoorChandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Russian Escorts in Delhi 9711199171 with low rate Book online
 
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
valvereliz227
 
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdfCLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
HannahDerenbach
 
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdfGUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
ProexportColombia1
 
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docxTiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
lamluanvan.net Viết thuê luận văn
 
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
khalnayak pandey
 
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7 Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
shaankumar98663
 
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
teenagarg #v08
 
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
hema sharman06
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home DeliveryIndian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
Indian Call Girls Noida 9873777170 Cash Payment Free Home Delivery
 
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
 
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdfDalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
 
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward SlidesSingapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
 
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
 
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
❣Mature Women / Aunty Call Girl Chennai 💯Call Us 🔝 7737669865 🔝💃Independent C...
 
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance PaymentCall Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
Call Girls Chennai 🎉 7339748667 🎉 With No Advance Payment
 
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(leeds学位证书)英国利兹大学毕业证如何办理
 
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
Call Girls in Mumbai (Maharashtra) call me [🔝9967824496🔝] Escort In Jaipur se...
 
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update SlidesSingapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
 
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of MoneyApplication Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
 
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your DoorChandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
 
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
2024欧洲杯赔率-2024欧洲杯赔率买球推荐网站-2024欧洲杯赔率买球网好的网站 |【​网址​🎉ac55.net🎉​】
 
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdfCLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
 
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdfGUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
GUIA_LEGAL_CHAPTER_13_ACCOUNTING REGULATION.pdf
 
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docxTiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
Tiểu luận: PURPOSE OF BUDGETING IN SME.docx
 
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
🚺MIHIKA JAIN Call Girls In Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 9352988975 🔝💃Top Class Call G...
 
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7 Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
Call Girls Bangalore 9024918724 Verified Service Available Near Me 24x7
 
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
 
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
 

The Housing Bubble and Financial Crisis: A New View

  • 1. A Radical New Understanding of the Housing Bubble and the Financial Crisis Presented by Kevin Erdmann
  • 2. The Housing Bubble So obvious, the premise didn’t need to be confirmed.
  • 3. There were never too many homes.
  • 4. NYC LA Boston San Fran. San Diego San Jose $0 $200,000 $400,000 $600,000 $800,000 $1,000,000 Median Home Rent and Price 50 Largest MSAs 1Q 1991 1Q 2007 1Q 2015 MedianHomePrice Median Annual Rent A handful of cities have become very expensive to live in – for both renters and owners.
  • 5. The housing bubble was an American refugee crisis. Americans were building new homes in order to reduce their housing expenses. -2.0% -1.0% 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 Rate of Net Domestic Migration Closed Access Cities Contagion Cities
  • 6. Before 2008: Housing markets were driven by supply. All prices increased. After 2008: Housing markets were driven by a credit shock. Low tier prices collapsed. 0.75 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00 2.25 2.50 Seattle Quintile 1 Quintile 2 Quintile 3 Quintile 4 Quintile 5 Zip codes, in quintiles by median home price. Jan. 2000 = 1 Supply Driven Migration Event Credit Shock 0.75 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00 2.25 2.50 Atlanta Quintile 1 Quintile 2 Quintile 3 Quintile 4 Quintile 5 Zip codes, in quintiles by median home price. Jan. 2000 = 1 Credit ShockSupply Driven Migration Event
  • 7. The rise of low-tier home prices in high priced cities had little to do with lending to households with low incomes. It was more likely a product of our highly regressive income tax subsidies to homeownership, which cause price/rent ratios to rise as home prices rise, up to a given price level, where they level off.
  • 8. Before 2008: Housing markets were driven by aspirational households buying into expensive cities and other households moving to cheaper cities to reduce costs. After 2008: Public focused on preventing households with lower incomes from over-buying. This had little to do with the bubble and left the core problems unaddressed. Family income quintiles and deciles
  • 9. Before 2008: Rates of homeownership were within long-term norms, when adjusted demographically. After 2008: Homeownership among young and less affluent households has declined. Homeownership in 2018 is much more sensitive to age and income than it was in 1995 or 2005, and homeownership rates are well below any modern norms. Family income quintiles and deciles
  • 10. In 2008, Federal regulators acted as if there was a credit problem when we had a supply problem. This cut home prices significantly, devastated homeowners’ equity, and locked young, first-time, and working class buyers out of the market. For those families, today, homeownership is a free lunch, if they can find a way to do it. 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 1979-03 1981-03 1983-03 1985-03 1987-03 1989-03 1991-03 1993-03 1995-03 1997-03 1999-03 2001-03 2003-03 2005-03 2007-03 2009-03 2011-03 2013-03 2015-03 2017-03 Mortgage Affordability vs. Rent Affordability Mortgage Affordability Rent Affordability Inflation & Cost Adjusted Mortgage Affordability Credit Shock = Unprecedented Affordability
  • 11. Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation Housing, especially at the low end, is greatly undervalued.
  • 12. Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation Housing, especially at the low end, is greatly undervalued...And obstacles to real investment – through local building codes and national lending policies – are pushing down real long term interest rates. Building more homes would solve the “safe asset shortage” problem. Investor Returns vs Owner Returns
  • 13. Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation Monetary inflation is perpetually overestimated, creating overly hawkish monetary policy.
  • 14. Implications for Wealth Management and Asset Allocation • We are in a boom-bust economic regime. This is blamed on demand (credit and money), but it is the result of structural obstacles to supply – most notably residence in economically dynamic cities. • This leads to hawkish monetary policy that is creating cyclical risk. • Real estate, and especially low-end real estate, appears to be more volatile and risky than previously thought. But, real estate volatility was due to a one-time negative demand shock that cannot be repeated. In that case, past volatility points to future stability and reversion to the mean. • Carefully chosen positions in real estate, lending, and homebuilding markets can provide both speculative and defensive opportunities for asset management, even though cyclical risks remain.
  翻译: