尊敬的 微信汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046166 元 支付宝汇率:1円 ≈ 0.046257元 [退出登录]
SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1
Les Réflexions de Comptoir
du Café de l’Economie
It seems that the world is going in the bad direction, at least, from an economic perspective. The high level of
debt that fuels the weak economic growth (or perhaps this is the other way around?) would be the main risk
for the world and in the end, a big financial crisis would be inevitable. This diagnosis is made by numerous
experts and is becoming the “mainstream view”.
We fully disagree. And we are tired of hearing all these analyses that rely on nothing more than fear and (bad)
intuition.
The world continues to change at a very fast pace. That’s the good news. It has always been the case since the
15th
century and there is no reason to think that this secular trend will stop soon (let’s find a cure for cancer
first!). However, this change has intensified recently with the coincidence of several events and it seems that
the legacy of this intensive period is hard to bear.
In 2016, we are left therefore with some economic agents that continue to advance but others that stay
behind. What are we talking about here? To make it short, although we can divide the economy in many parts,
we can group them into two groups: the one that we call the “new economy” (mainly non financial services
sectors) and the other one that we call the “old economy” (commodity, industry, finance, construction). At the
global level, the trajectory of these two economies has been very similar in the 2000/2010 decade but it
appears that it was just a coincidence. Now their trajectories are diverging again and this is, in our opinion,
the main problem of the world economy today.
Thus, the main problem is NOT the weak economic growth worldwide, the problem is the weakness of the
“old economy” all around the world. And the countries in which the “old economy” is important suffer the
most whilst the countries that are more geared towards the “new economy” continue to grow.
The “top down analysis” is dying with the rise of this divergence. If we look at France, where citizens like to
moan, to complain about what is bad, where we can find experts saying “social security charges are too high”
we can clearly see the divergence between the new and the old economy. We show below the dynamic of the
employment, split into industry and services as a proxy of the new and old economy. The message is crystal
clear: the problem of the French economy is the weight of the underperforming old economy.
Source: Bloomberg
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
120
2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015
France - Services
France - Industry
US Total
Base 100
= Jan.00
Employment: France vs. US
2
The debt problem is not universal; it concerns developed countries first of all. Knowing that the industry sector
is more capital intensive by nature than the services sector and knowing that, by definition, a debt is a legacy,
we understand very well why the debt problem is without any surprise related to the old economy in the old
world.
How did we get there? Our understanding is that monetary and budgetary authorities in the developed world
have not accepted to see the collapse of the old economy. We mean that authorities are sensitive to the
social cost of the technology cycle. In other words, because the social well-being of a nation is the #1
objective (in economic terms this notion is called “minimizing the unemployment rate”) central banks have
to lower rates and budget policies have to be expansive to support the failing parts of the economy.
That’s a key point.
Experts say “monetary policy does not work”. The fact is that addressing the weakness of an old factory by
lowering its funding cost will for sure bring limited results in the end. Everybody understands that. The old
factory needs a stronger order book and decreasing interest rates from 2% to 0% will not change dramatically
its fate.
So why interest rates are so low today? 1) because the old economy is in a deflationary mode and 2) the social
cost of letting it collapsing is too high for governments. The policies that address the old economy are not very
efficient but it has to be seen as a strategy to save time.
Also, from this perspective, the level of debt in developed countries can be seen as an indicator mixing the
weight of the old economy, the efficiency of this old economy and the willingness of the government to
support this falling economy.
Source: Bloomberg
The question of the inflation rate is not important. Inflation is a consequence, not a cause. The above chart
reflects the two economies story. The services economy is back to trend so inflation in the services sector is
back to trend. The old economy is in a distressed situation so inflation in the old economy is flirting with
negative territory.
We understand here that there are two possibilities to see inflation becoming a genuine threat: 1) the new
economy becomes so strong that its inflation rate overshoots or 2) the old economy stabilizes, escapes the
deflationary zone and its inflation rate recovers towards 1%.
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
1995 1999 2003 2007 2011 2015 2019
Goods ex
Food&Energy
Services ex-
Energy
Inflation rate in the US
3
The equity market is telling us nicely this story. Looking at the relative performance of the Nasdaq against the
FTSEMIB index (the Italian equity index) the natural human reaction would be to argue that “the ratio is too
high, trees cannot grow to the sky, there is big risk of reversal”. The reality is that if this ratio is high, it is
simply because the profits of the Nasdaq have grown far faster than the profits of the FTSEMIB. The Nasdaq is
made of companies that will rule the world tomorrow whilst the two biggest listed Italian companies are Enel
and ENI.
Source: Bloomberg
So make your choice: do you want to be the shareholder of Google and Facebook or do you want to be the co-
shareholder (with the Italian Ministry for the Economy and Finance) of companies that produce electricity and
oil?
We do not know if trees can reach the sky but we think that these companies of the new economy can bring us
very high in the sky.
In sum, there is no anomaly to see on one side the Nasdaq index at an all time high, and on the other side,
high debt and high unemployment in the most inefficient parts of the old developed world. There is no
contradiction here but two different trajectories and public intervention to reduce this divergence.
We stop here as we are neither journalist, nor writer and we do not pretend we have an idea on everything.
Economic sciences are extremely complex so our goal here was just to offer another angle of thinking
regarding the “global growth analysis”. Things are never binary, the mainstream view is not necessarily the
correct view.
Tristan Abet
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015
Base 100
= Mar.00
Nasdaq / FTSEMIB ratio
the anomaly in history

More Related Content

What's hot

CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
Mercatus Center
 
To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009
Swedbank
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital ltd
 
The 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
The 2009 Interest Rate OutlookThe 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
The 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
nicoforest
 
Economic Review And Outlook
Economic Review And OutlookEconomic Review And Outlook
Economic Review And Outlook
guestfd180e4
 
Amph 0410 2
Amph 0410 2Amph 0410 2
Amph 0410 2
boylanj
 
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
radhikaburman
 
Causes of and solution for the economic crisis
Causes of and solution for the economic crisisCauses of and solution for the economic crisis
Causes of and solution for the economic crisis
WilfredBerendsen
 
The Great Leveraging-Comments
The Great Leveraging-CommentsThe Great Leveraging-Comments
The Great Leveraging-Comments
Mirra Nabila Sukri
 
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin FoundationMichael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
BizTimes Media
 
Keynesian theory of money
Keynesian theory of moneyKeynesian theory of money
Keynesian theory of money
Dina Ertoleu
 
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensusModule 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
American School of Guatemala
 
Is lm model
Is lm modelIs lm model
Is lm model
BhawnaBhardwaj24
 
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that CountAgcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
Veripath Partners
 
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
Mercatus Center
 
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
Mercatus Center
 
keynesianism vs monetarism
keynesianism vs monetarismkeynesianism vs monetarism
keynesianism vs monetarism
Sudarshan Kadariya
 
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Goteo / Platoniq
 
3532391 inflation
3532391 inflation3532391 inflation
3532391 inflation
sealfonso
 
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
guest19e4c
 

What's hot (20)

CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
CHC: A Quarterly Economic Update Jan 2010
 
To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
 
The 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
The 2009 Interest Rate OutlookThe 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
The 2009 Interest Rate Outlook
 
Economic Review And Outlook
Economic Review And OutlookEconomic Review And Outlook
Economic Review And Outlook
 
Amph 0410 2
Amph 0410 2Amph 0410 2
Amph 0410 2
 
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
Us economy - Is the recovery for real???
 
Causes of and solution for the economic crisis
Causes of and solution for the economic crisisCauses of and solution for the economic crisis
Causes of and solution for the economic crisis
 
The Great Leveraging-Comments
The Great Leveraging-CommentsThe Great Leveraging-Comments
The Great Leveraging-Comments
 
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin FoundationMichael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
Michael Knetter, Ph.D. - President of the University of Wisconsin Foundation
 
Keynesian theory of money
Keynesian theory of moneyKeynesian theory of money
Keynesian theory of money
 
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensusModule 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
Module 36 the modern macroeconomic consensus
 
Is lm model
Is lm modelIs lm model
Is lm model
 
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that CountAgcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
Agcapita - February 27 2012 - Charts that Count
 
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
 
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
A Quarterly Economic Update March 2010
 
keynesianism vs monetarism
keynesianism vs monetarismkeynesianism vs monetarism
keynesianism vs monetarism
 
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
 
3532391 inflation
3532391 inflation3532391 inflation
3532391 inflation
 
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
Crisis And Economic Outlook For 2008
 

Viewers also liked

Programme salon e commerce paris 2013
Programme salon e commerce paris  2013Programme salon e commerce paris  2013
Programme salon e commerce paris 2013Charlotte Le Dall
 
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaborationMercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
Marion Gaillardet
 
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des CotonniersLancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
Verseau Paris
 
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
BEDOUET David
 
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia WatchVers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
Altavia
 
Inspirations RSE pour le retail
Inspirations RSE pour le retail Inspirations RSE pour le retail
Inspirations RSE pour le retail
Altavia
 
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail internationalBest of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
Altavia
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Programme salon e commerce paris 2013
Programme salon e commerce paris  2013Programme salon e commerce paris  2013
Programme salon e commerce paris 2013
 
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaborationMercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
Mercado Global + Comptoir des Cotonniers collaboration
 
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des CotonniersLancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
Lancement des soldes par la marque Comptoir des Cotonniers
 
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
Les chiffres clé de l'e-commerce en France en 2010
 
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia WatchVers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
Vers des consommateurs responsables? par Altavia Watch
 
Inspirations RSE pour le retail
Inspirations RSE pour le retail Inspirations RSE pour le retail
Inspirations RSE pour le retail
 
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail internationalBest of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
Best of 2016 Altavia Watch du Retail international
 

Similar to Les réflexions de comptoir 2 - Oct2016

Winter is coming (1) (2)
Winter is coming (1) (2)Winter is coming (1) (2)
Winter is coming (1) (2)
Davin Appanah
 
Lifting the small boats
Lifting the small boatsLifting the small boats
Lifting the small boats
ananto widodo
 
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The NextSaying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
Edward Hugh
 
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Rudy Belouad
 
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury GroupsDeloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Digitaluxe
 
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexusPart 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
Brian David Butler
 
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Caution gcc economies
Caution gcc economiesCaution gcc economies
Caution gcc economies
team-abr
 
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdfAnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
sutharbharat59
 
Where's the money going
Where's the money going Where's the money going
Where's the money going
TariqCarrimjee
 
The real effects of debt bis
The real effects of debt bisThe real effects of debt bis
The real effects of debt bis
neiracar
 
East europe's demographic problems
East europe's demographic problemsEast europe's demographic problems
East europe's demographic problems
Edward Hugh
 
The Super-Cycle Report
The Super-Cycle ReportThe Super-Cycle Report
The Super-Cycle Report
Ufuk Kılıç
 

Similar to Les réflexions de comptoir 2 - Oct2016 (13)

Winter is coming (1) (2)
Winter is coming (1) (2)Winter is coming (1) (2)
Winter is coming (1) (2)
 
Lifting the small boats
Lifting the small boatsLifting the small boats
Lifting the small boats
 
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The NextSaying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
Saying Goodbye To One Crisis and Hello To The Next
 
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
Global Powers of Luxury Goods 2014
 
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury GroupsDeloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
Deloitte 2014: Global Powers of Luxury Groups
 
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexusPart 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
Part 10 athens finance class summer 2010 forum nexus
 
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
From Crisis to Recovery The Causes, Course and Consequences of the Great Rece...
 
Caution gcc economies
Caution gcc economiesCaution gcc economies
Caution gcc economies
 
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdfAnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
AnsA) When financial markets stood on the verge of collapse in th.pdf
 
Where's the money going
Where's the money going Where's the money going
Where's the money going
 
The real effects of debt bis
The real effects of debt bisThe real effects of debt bis
The real effects of debt bis
 
East europe's demographic problems
East europe's demographic problemsEast europe's demographic problems
East europe's demographic problems
 
The Super-Cycle Report
The Super-Cycle ReportThe Super-Cycle Report
The Super-Cycle Report
 

Recently uploaded

Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
khannsohil539
 
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
Henry Tapper
 
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdfCLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
HannahDerenbach
 
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your DoorChandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Russian Escorts in Delhi 9711199171 with low rate Book online
 
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
Godwin Emmanuel Oyedokun MBA MSc PhD FCA FCTI FCNA CFE FFAR
 
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
teenagarg #v08
 
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts ServiceCall Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
kartikkumar4563
 
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in MadiwalaEscorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
aroanasingh
 
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdfDalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Henry Tapper
 
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education SlidesSingapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
International Federation of Accountants
 
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdfVadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
johnson100mee
 
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
priya$L14
 
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
Henry Tapper
 
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of MoneyApplication Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
vineetabhati1
 
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
heatherhamood
 
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
giihuu300#S07
 
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURECall Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
tiya sharma
 
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
hema sharman06
 
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward SlidesSingapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
International Federation of Accountants
 
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update SlidesSingapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
International Federation of Accountants
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
Independent Call Girls Visakhapatnam 8800000000 Low Rate HIgh Profile Visakha...
 
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
Pension Playpen - TAS300 v2 maths and governance resets pension strategies (3...
 
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdfCLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
CLUB DEAL - UK - 210524 - DECK INVESTOR.pdf
 
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your DoorChandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
Chandigarh Call Girls 7339748667 With Free Home Delivery At Your Door
 
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
The Accountancy Profession and National Anti-Corruption 2024 Strategy Prof. O...
 
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
🔥Verified Call Girls Ahmedabad 💯Call Us 🔝 8094342248 🔝💃Top Class Call Girl Se...
 
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts ServiceCall Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
Call Girls Hyderabad 7742996321 Hyderabad Escorts Service
 
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in MadiwalaEscorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
Escorts Service Madiwala 9113698327 Independent Escorts in Madiwala
 
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdfDalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
Dalriada Submission to DWP January 2024.pdf
 
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education SlidesSingapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
Singapore 2024 Sustainability Reporting and Accountancy Education Slides
 
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdfVadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
Vadhavan Port Development _ What to Expect In and Beyond (1).pdf
 
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
💋High Profile Call Girls Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝 9999965857 🔝💃Independent Delhi Esco...
 
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
20240620-ae-contributions-briefing-paper-final.pdf
 
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of MoneyApplication Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
Application Of mathematics in Finance- Time Value of Money
 
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
Heather Elizabeth HamoodHeather Elizabeth Hamood
 
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
Call Girls In Coimbatore👯‍♀️ 7339748667 🔥 Safe Housewife Call Girl Service Ho...
 
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURECall Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
Call Girls In Chennai 7339748667 BEST GIRL SERVICE IN FULL SAFE AND SECURE
 
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
🔥Jamshedpur Call Girls 🫱 7023059433 🫲 High Class Independent Escorts Service ...
 
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward SlidesSingapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
Singapore 2024 Event The Way Forward Slides
 
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update SlidesSingapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
Singapore Event 2024 IPSASB Update Slides
 

Les réflexions de comptoir 2 - Oct2016

  • 1. 1 Les Réflexions de Comptoir du Café de l’Economie It seems that the world is going in the bad direction, at least, from an economic perspective. The high level of debt that fuels the weak economic growth (or perhaps this is the other way around?) would be the main risk for the world and in the end, a big financial crisis would be inevitable. This diagnosis is made by numerous experts and is becoming the “mainstream view”. We fully disagree. And we are tired of hearing all these analyses that rely on nothing more than fear and (bad) intuition. The world continues to change at a very fast pace. That’s the good news. It has always been the case since the 15th century and there is no reason to think that this secular trend will stop soon (let’s find a cure for cancer first!). However, this change has intensified recently with the coincidence of several events and it seems that the legacy of this intensive period is hard to bear. In 2016, we are left therefore with some economic agents that continue to advance but others that stay behind. What are we talking about here? To make it short, although we can divide the economy in many parts, we can group them into two groups: the one that we call the “new economy” (mainly non financial services sectors) and the other one that we call the “old economy” (commodity, industry, finance, construction). At the global level, the trajectory of these two economies has been very similar in the 2000/2010 decade but it appears that it was just a coincidence. Now their trajectories are diverging again and this is, in our opinion, the main problem of the world economy today. Thus, the main problem is NOT the weak economic growth worldwide, the problem is the weakness of the “old economy” all around the world. And the countries in which the “old economy” is important suffer the most whilst the countries that are more geared towards the “new economy” continue to grow. The “top down analysis” is dying with the rise of this divergence. If we look at France, where citizens like to moan, to complain about what is bad, where we can find experts saying “social security charges are too high” we can clearly see the divergence between the new and the old economy. We show below the dynamic of the employment, split into industry and services as a proxy of the new and old economy. The message is crystal clear: the problem of the French economy is the weight of the underperforming old economy. Source: Bloomberg 75 80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 France - Services France - Industry US Total Base 100 = Jan.00 Employment: France vs. US
  • 2. 2 The debt problem is not universal; it concerns developed countries first of all. Knowing that the industry sector is more capital intensive by nature than the services sector and knowing that, by definition, a debt is a legacy, we understand very well why the debt problem is without any surprise related to the old economy in the old world. How did we get there? Our understanding is that monetary and budgetary authorities in the developed world have not accepted to see the collapse of the old economy. We mean that authorities are sensitive to the social cost of the technology cycle. In other words, because the social well-being of a nation is the #1 objective (in economic terms this notion is called “minimizing the unemployment rate”) central banks have to lower rates and budget policies have to be expansive to support the failing parts of the economy. That’s a key point. Experts say “monetary policy does not work”. The fact is that addressing the weakness of an old factory by lowering its funding cost will for sure bring limited results in the end. Everybody understands that. The old factory needs a stronger order book and decreasing interest rates from 2% to 0% will not change dramatically its fate. So why interest rates are so low today? 1) because the old economy is in a deflationary mode and 2) the social cost of letting it collapsing is too high for governments. The policies that address the old economy are not very efficient but it has to be seen as a strategy to save time. Also, from this perspective, the level of debt in developed countries can be seen as an indicator mixing the weight of the old economy, the efficiency of this old economy and the willingness of the government to support this falling economy. Source: Bloomberg The question of the inflation rate is not important. Inflation is a consequence, not a cause. The above chart reflects the two economies story. The services economy is back to trend so inflation in the services sector is back to trend. The old economy is in a distressed situation so inflation in the old economy is flirting with negative territory. We understand here that there are two possibilities to see inflation becoming a genuine threat: 1) the new economy becomes so strong that its inflation rate overshoots or 2) the old economy stabilizes, escapes the deflationary zone and its inflation rate recovers towards 1%. -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 1995 1999 2003 2007 2011 2015 2019 Goods ex Food&Energy Services ex- Energy Inflation rate in the US
  • 3. 3 The equity market is telling us nicely this story. Looking at the relative performance of the Nasdaq against the FTSEMIB index (the Italian equity index) the natural human reaction would be to argue that “the ratio is too high, trees cannot grow to the sky, there is big risk of reversal”. The reality is that if this ratio is high, it is simply because the profits of the Nasdaq have grown far faster than the profits of the FTSEMIB. The Nasdaq is made of companies that will rule the world tomorrow whilst the two biggest listed Italian companies are Enel and ENI. Source: Bloomberg So make your choice: do you want to be the shareholder of Google and Facebook or do you want to be the co- shareholder (with the Italian Ministry for the Economy and Finance) of companies that produce electricity and oil? We do not know if trees can reach the sky but we think that these companies of the new economy can bring us very high in the sky. In sum, there is no anomaly to see on one side the Nasdaq index at an all time high, and on the other side, high debt and high unemployment in the most inefficient parts of the old developed world. There is no contradiction here but two different trajectories and public intervention to reduce this divergence. We stop here as we are neither journalist, nor writer and we do not pretend we have an idea on everything. Economic sciences are extremely complex so our goal here was just to offer another angle of thinking regarding the “global growth analysis”. Things are never binary, the mainstream view is not necessarily the correct view. Tristan Abet 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 Base 100 = Mar.00 Nasdaq / FTSEMIB ratio the anomaly in history
  翻译: